By Alice Kazakov
In July of 2023 the European Parliament narrowly passed what is considered to be a controversial bill called the Nature Restoration Law. The law is just another step in the EU’s plan of action to conserve and protect ecosystems while battling effects from climate change. Since then, a series of trilogue negotiations have taken place among the Parliament, the Commission, and the Council to come to an agreement on their respective proposals and finalize the bill.
However, with the bill mainly focusing on agriculture and forestation, nongovernmental organizations warn of a failure to address fisheries impacts and the challenges with collaborative marine conservation.
Nicolas Fournier, Europe Campaign Director at Oceana stated “I think the Commission was very shy and didn't want to open up a whole fight with the Common Fishing Policy so they made the assumption that fisheries would adjust naturally and member states would make these necessary steps.”
The law includes language for long terms commitments and measures that would cover 20% of land and sea in the EU by 2030 and cover all areas needing restoration by 2050, as according to the European Commission website under “Nature Restoration Law.” EU member states are being tasked with providing recommendations and policies for how they will commit to the different goals.
For marine ecosystems, the law aims at restoring and preserving sensitive habitats as well as allowing species to recover to sustainable levels.
NGOs like Oceana, Client Earth, and Seas at Risk warn the EU however, that without first tackling fisheries management policies and cooperation between all member states, marine restoration is simply not possible.
To address this, Parliament added a segment in its adoption of the law, titled Article 14a, that would require member states to submit joint recommendations and agreements for restoration actions and management practices. A country whose fisheries may impact the marine restoration in another will be held accountable by a binding joint agreement.
Fournier explains that this article adds an additional roadblock to
making this law successful, and some member states do not have the same invested interest.
“It might be dozens of joint recommendation processes and on average those can take several years. So, there is an element of timing which is not synchronized. There's also a risk that a country has all the good intention in the world but they get blocked in their joint recommendation process by other countries," Fournier said.
Another issue, according to Client Earth senior lawyer John Condon, is that the article may not even be included in the final rendition of the bill. Condon expressed he was surprised it made it into the original proposal considering certain countries invest more into fisheries than environmental management.
“A fundamental principle of the common fisheries policy is that fishing vessels from member states have equal access to all of that area, which is the majority of the marine environment in the EU,” Condon explained.
Member states are allowed to establish marine protected areas, ban certain methods and constitute specific regulations within 12 nautical miles off their shore, but beyond that point it is much harder to control the actions of fisheries from other countries.
Article 11, or the joint recommendation procedure of the Common Fishing Policy aims to address this. In this provision, if a member state declares the goals and conservation measures they plan to take to reach total restoration, they need to consult and agree with other member states that have fishing interests in the area. A procedure like this already exists for setting Total Allowable Catches, which are imposed on every member state regardless of location or invested interest.
"The basic problem is that the countries who have those fishing interests in the Exclusive Economic Zone, they don't particularly have an incentive to agree to conservation because as far as they're concerned, it's not really their territory or it's not their EEZ," Condon elaborated. "They're predominantly concerned to protect the interests of their own fishing vessels."
Condon explained that methods such as bottom trawling are still being used in what should be marine protected areas in offshore zones, which no member state have claim to and are under no obligation to agree to any restrictions.
“Now we have this idea of a nature restoration law which is aiming to achieve restoration. But NGOs are saying, 'how is this going to happen if you were relying on a system that has been shown not to work and how are you going to achieve restoration in that offshore space?' And that is what article 14 is trying to address,” Condon said.
A proposal from the European Parliament suggests the adopted text include more specific language and precise goals, an example being deadlines for state members to submit join recommendations to. If a joint recommendation cannot be agreed upon for certain conservation measures, then ultimate power will be given to the Commission to take action and enact strict protection zones.
Condon explained that the provision is important to fixing pre-existing issues but he is interested to see what will come out of it since Parliament disputed a majority of what the Commission originally proposed.
“At the moment Article 14a is being watered down in terms of it becoming less ambitious,” he said, citing the last-minute backlash from the European People’s Party in Parliament as the reason for setting lower targets.
Louis Lambrechts, Ocean Policy Officer at Worldwide Fund for Nature, argues that without the agreement of all member states for conservation measures, sustainable fishing and proper fisheries management is simply not possible.
“Every rule is only as good as its implementation, and that’s in the hands of the Member States,” he said, “Even land-locked member states must play their part!”
Once the final legislation has been proposed, NGOs like Client Earth, Seas at Risk, WWF and others will draft statement letters, scientific recommendations and more to ensure ambitious goals and targets are being set in alignment with the CFP.
Part of what organizations like Client Earth feel responsible for doing, as stated by Condon, is making sure that a topic this technical and dense is able to be understood by the public. Whether through statement pieces, press releases or social media posts, they aim to convey the messages and potential outcomes in a more condensable way for people that are not experts in ocean or conservation regulations.
“It's just interesting to observe that this has become a story in national press when a lot of the time what happens in the EU is considered quite boring and technical even though it's of fundamental importance to every EU citizen. This one is the high-level issue has got a lot of attention,” Condon concluded.
The final round of trilogue negotiations is set to take place in just a couple of weeks to finalize the text and proposals.