Colo. Supreme Court Blocks Progress of Public Trust Doctrine Measure

Water policy watchdogs across Colorado breathed a small sigh of relief this week upon learning that Initiative 103, the so-called “Public Trust Doctrine” measure, will not make it onto the state-wide ballot this November.

The Colorado Supreme Court rejected the initiative by a vote of 4-3 on a technicality earlier this week, ruling that one of its two authors incorrectly sent a substitute to a state hearing on the measure. The decision, which validates a May 1 appeal by the Colorado Water Congress and Coloradoans for Responsible Reform, blocks the initiative from proceeding toward the 2014 ballot.

Initiative 103 was one of a host of proposed initiatives that emerged earlier this year, which opponents suspect were ultimately designed to undermine drilling and fracking in Colorado. But its more immediate effect would have been to dismantle Colorado’s 150-year-old water rights system known as the Prior Appropriations Doctrine which establishes water rights as private property, while claiming to restore those rights to the public.

Written by former Department of the Interior staffer Philip Doe (of the grassroots group Be The Change U.S.A) and Barbara Mills-Bria, the proposed Initiative 103 begins with a broad appeal that “people of Colorado have an inalienable right to clean air, clean water, and the preservation of the environment and natural resources.”

A citizen lawsuit provision would make it easier for citizens to sue polluters while demanding “that people or organizations pay a legal price for spreading misinformation for profit about the environment and the environmental risks posed by industrial activities like drilling,” according to the Colorado Independent.

For water rights holders of all stripes, the most disturbing part of the proposed initiative was a provision that “previous rights and agreements on the use of resources are subject to the substantial impairment test, and could be revoked.”

“It’s a very misguided approach, a nuclear explosion for a situation that should be handled a hammer and chisel,” said Andy Mueller, a Ouray attorney who sits on the Colorado River Board.

Chief Justice Hobbs was the first to evoke that apocalyptic imagery. He described an earlier iteration of the Public Trust Initiative in 2012 as proposing to “drop what amounts to a nuclear bomb on Colorado water rights.” Its passage, he wrote in a dissenting opinion that year, could “cause voter surprise and fraud by the inadvertent passage of surreptitious provisions coiled up in the folds of a complex initiative.”

The 2012 measure ultimately failed to gather enough signatures to land on the ballot. The Supreme Court’s decision this week means that Public Trust Doctrine opponents have dodged another bullet. But according to a release from the Colorado Water Stewardship Project which monitors and challenges all ballot filings and legal actions for a Public Trust Doctrine, ballot proponents “have promised to return with another proposal in 2016.”

Meanwhile, ballot language has been set for two other initiatives that could ultimately have much the same effect on Colorado water law as Initiative 103. Initiative 89 (Local Government Regulation of Environment) describes all natural resources in Colorado as being a public trust that the state should be protecting, and was recently cleared for signature collection, as was Initiative 75 (Right to Local Self-Government), which would strengthen “local control,” allowing local governments to adopt environmental regulations that override state laws.

“Initiatives 75 and 89 are just as much a threat to Colorado’s water resources as Initiative 103 and should be taken seriously,” warned the Colorado Water Stewardship Project in a release on Monday.

Jason Ullman, Assistant Division Engineer with the Colorado Division of Water Resources Division 4, is among those who have been watching the progress of all three initiatives carefully.

“Definitely, the Public Trust Doctrine would be a huge change in the way that water law works in Colorado and probably change is not always a good thing,” he said, careful to point out that as a government employee he can’t take an official position on any of the measures. “No one would deny some changes could be made – minor ones in how water is adjudicated – but to throw the whole system out would have a huge impact on all the folks who rely on certainty of existing water rights.

“These measures would open the door for tons of law suits to be filed by anybody that felt like the state was not protecting natural resources way they think they should be protected. That alone could be a huge problem for everyone in the state.”