Title: The Making of Biblical Womanhood: How the Subjugation of Women Became Gospel Truth
Author: Beth Allison Barr
Book Publisher: Brazos Press (2021)
Review Publisher: U.S. Catholic (October 2022)
A professor of history at Baylor University as well as a pastor’s wife, Beth Allison Barr opens The Making of Biblical Womanhood with her own story of silence. Her husband was a youth pastor until he tangled with his church’s leadership over women in ministry. His termination opened a floodgate of emotion for Barr, and she channeled it into this book.
Barr writes as a practicing Baptist to an evangelical audience, drawing on her training as a medieval historian to explore the origins of Christian patriarchy, a system older than Christianity. Evidence of it, Barr argues, can be found in world literature as far back as The Epic of Gilgamesh. This patriarchal legacy continues in Christianity. The question for many Christians is whether “Christian patriarchy” is inherently better. Barr argues that Christian patriarchy is just patriarchy unleavened by gospel values.
Catholics are not Barr’s intended audience, but her research is invaluable for American Catholics who have watched evangelical influences seep into the church. Arguing that the New Testament’s “household codes” had little influence on medieval understandings of marriage, Barr references Catholic writers such as John Mirk and Peter Abelard who taught that a woman’s first allegiance was not to her husband but to Christ. The wedding ring, Mirk wrote, reminds a woman that “she shall love God over all things and then her husband.”
Barr’s book ends with a deeply personal story of how Christian patriarchy harmed her. Although hesitant to sketch a way forward, she calls upon Christian women to stand together, to find their voice. “Jesus set women free a long time ago,” she writes. “Isn’t it finally time for evangelical Christians to do the same?” Isn’t it time for Catholics to do so too?
(Image: Blackbird, fox, and books; Pixabay.)