The Lord’s Day Is Not a Christian Sabbath

When I became Catholic after a nominal Seventh-Day Adventist upbringing, I accepted the argument of some Catholic apologists that the Church had changed the Sabbath from Saturday to Sunday on the basis of the teaching authority granted to the Church by Christ. In an early foray into apologetics for This Rock, the predecessor of Catholic Answers Magazine, I wrote in response to a question of whether the Church was wrong to “change” the Sabbath from Saturday to Sunday:

Not by a long shot. . . . While it is true that there is no New Testament record of a voice from the heavens instructing the infant Church, ‘Thou shalt change the day of thy worship and rest from Saturday to Sunday,’ Adventists are mistaken in their belief that there is no New Testament evidence that supports such a change by the Catholic Church” (This Rock, April 1997).

As a recent convert and eager new apologist, I had made a mistake: I trusted without question Catholic apologists who had gone before me in defense of the faith, which is not the same thing as trusting the Church and the faith it professes.

As but one example of a trope engaged in by Catholic apologists on the subject, let’s look at Fr. Leslie Rumble and Fr. Charles Carty, the famed priest apologists of the mid-twentieth century who compiled Radio Replies, a classic resource of questions and answers on the Catholic faith. The radio priests answered a question about the “change” of day this way:

In due time [God] sent his Son, who established the Catholic Church, and [the Church] tells us God’s present law. . . . The Jews decided to observe Saturday [as the Sabbath], while Christians decided to observe Sunday. The seventh day as God’s day was not changed. The Sabbath, God’s rest day, was transferred from Saturday to Sunday (vol. I, p. 235).

There are a number of problems with this response. Rather than examine them in detail, I will let this stand as an example of a common apologetic response and focus my attention on giving what I hope is a better answer to the issue of Christian corporate worship and rest on Sunday, or, as the New Testament calls it, “the first day of the week” (Matt. 28:1; Mark 16:2, 9; Luke 24:1; John 20:1, 19; Acts 20:7; 1 Cor. 16:2).

In the beginning . . .

Seventh-Day Adventists often begin their defense of Christian observance of the Sabbath by turning to the creation stories in Genesis and claiming that on the seventh day God “made the Sabbath” and “blessed it”:

If God finished the creation on the sixth day (Gen. 2:1), what does Scripture mean when it says that he “ended his work” on the seventh day (Gen. 2:2)? God had finished the creation of the heavens and the earth in those six days, but he had yet to make the Sabbath. It was by resting on the Sabbath that he made it. The Sabbath was his finishing touch, ending his work (Seventh-Day Adventists Believe . . . , p. 250).

One difficulty with this scriptural interpretation is that the Sabbath is not mentioned in Genesis. The first mention of the Sabbath as a holy day created by the Lord is in Exodus 16:23, when Moses gives the Lord’s answer to the Israelites pining for Egypt and its plentiful food with a miraculous supply of bread:

“[Moses] said to them, ‘This is what the Lord has commanded: Tomorrow is a day of solemn rest, a holy Sabbath to the Lord; bake what you will bake and boil what you will boil, and all that is left over lay by to be kept till the morning.’”

Not only is the Sabbath as a holy day created in the context of the appearance of the manna that prefigures the Eucharist; it is a law announced by Moses, which means that the Sabbath is part of the Mosaic Law. This is a significant point to make with Adventists, because when asked why they keep only some elements of Mosaic Law (e.g., the Sabbath, avoiding unclean meats), many Adventists respond that they keep those elements of the Law of Moses given by God before the time of Moses and carried over into his Law.

But if the Sabbath was announced by Moses and is a part of the Law of Moses, then what was going on in Genesis?

Genesis 2 states: “And on the seventh day God finished his work which he had done, and he rested on the seventh day from all his work which he had done. So God blessed the seventh day and hallowed it, because on it God rested from all his work which he had done in creation” (2:2-3).

See what happened? The text of Genesis states that God blessed and hallowed the seventh day, not the Sabbath. Adventists conflate the seventh day with the Sabbath and read back into the Genesis story a divine creation of the Sabbath that Scripture records as having occurred much later.

This is one of those “Gotcha!” moments that can tempt a Catholic apologist to become smug. “How could anyone not see something so obvious?” we might be tempted to think. Not so fast. As we shall see, Catholic apologists have also been guilty of conflation.

A new heaven and a new earth

In his book Jesus of Nazareth, Pope Benedict XVI engages in discussion with Jewish scholar Rabbi Jacob Neusner about the person of Christ. Pope Benedict recounts a scene in the rabbi’s book, A Rabbi Talks with Jesus, in which the Rabbi Neusner imagines himself in Jesus’ time consulting with a fellow rabbi about this strange new prophet. Neusner’s consultant wants to know if Jesus has left out of his teaching any of the divine revelation given to Moses. No. The teacher then asks, “Then what did he add?” Neusner’s response: “Himself” (vol., 1, pp. 104–105). In response to this dialogue, Pope Benedict notes, “Jesus understands himself as the Torah—as the Word of God in person. . . . The heart of the Sabbath disputes is the question about the Son of Man—the question about Jesus Christ himself” (pp. 110–111).

Jesus the New Lawgiver has plenty to say about the Sabbath and one significant thing he does not say. He challenges interpretations of Sabbath law that would exclude doing good on the Sabbath (Matt. 12:12); he insists that man was not made for the Sabbath and that he himself is “Lord of the Sabbath” (Mark 2:27-28); he even suggests that the children of Abraham should be freed on the Sabbath from all that unjustly binds them (Luke 13:15-16). One thing he does not do is to restate the Sabbath commandment, even though he restates the other nine of the Ten Commandments (Matt. 4:10, 5:34, 19:18-19; Luke 12:15).

In the apostolic age, the apostles, commissioned by Christ to teach in his name (Matt. 16:18-19, 18:18-20, 28:19-20), emphasize the new order that Christ’s advent created. In Acts, Christians gather on the first day to “break bread” (20:7); the apostle Paul gives additional instructions for what Christians should do when they come together on the first day (1 Cor. 16:2); and Paul emphasizes that the holy days of old—whether they be festival, new moon, or Sabbath—no longer bind the Christian conscience (Col. 2:16).

This is a profound change in salvation history, and its pull is the work of Christ on the cross: “And you, who were dead in trespasses and the uncircumcision of your flesh, God made alive together with him, having forgiven us all our trespasses, having canceled the bond which stood against us with its legal demands; this he set aside, nailing it to the cross” (Col. 2:13-14). In this passage Paul not only declares that the Sabbath no longer binds Christians, he places it beside circumcision as something that has been nailed to the cross.

The Fathers of the Church continued this theme. The Didache, a first-century document notable for being “The Lord’s Teaching through the Twelve Apostles to the Nations [i.e., the Gentiles],” echoes the book of Revelation by calling the first day “the Lord’s Day” (Rev. 1:10, Didache 14). The apostle John’s student Ignatius of Antioch makes clear the distinction between the Sabbath and the Lord’s Day understood by the apostles:

If, therefore, those [Jewish Christians] who were brought up in the ancient order of things have come to the possession of a new hope, no longer observing the Sabbath, but living in the observance of the Lord’s Day, on which also our life has sprung up again by [Christ] and by his death . . . how shall we be able to live apart from him, whose disciples the prophets themselves in the Spirit did wait for him as their Teacher? (Letter to the Magnesians 9).

For hundreds of years Christians were united in their understanding that the Sabbath was a Jewish holy day, no longer incumbent on Christians to observe because of Christ’s work on the cross, as explicated by the teaching of his apostles and the first generations to follow them. What happened?

The Second Coming that wasn’t

On October 23, 1844, Hiram Edson (1806-1882) was a crushed man. He and many others had great faith that the previous day would see Christ’s Second Coming. William Miller (1782-1849), a Baptist preacher, had been promising the Second Coming for more than a decade. When Christ failed to show up, Edson refused to be dissuaded that a mistake had been made. With some friends, he decided to visit some fellow believers to lift their spirits after the Great Disappointment (as the episode would become known).

Edson claimed later that during this jaunt the heavens opened and it was revealed to him that Christ had retreated to an inner sanctum of heaven rather than return to earth. This heavenly movement coincided with a new movement of Christian seventh-day Sabbath observance that had started shortly before the Great Disappointment, and Seventh-Day Adventism was born.

The Seventh-Day Adventists had a few simple questions. Why should Christians observe Sunday as the Sabbath when that was a “change” instituted by the Catholic Church, the shackles of whose authority had been thrown off at the Protestant Reformation? If Christians were to properly observe the Sabbath, shouldn’t they do so on the seventh day, the day the Bible gave for that holy day, in the Ten Commandments no less (Exod. 20:9-11)?

Undergirding these questions was an assumption that had been growing unchecked among Christians for centuries: that Sunday was “the Christian Sabbath.” The idea took root among the Puritans, who sought to reclaim Old Testament observances and refashion them for Christian use (e.g., the first American Thanksgiving may have been patterned after the Old Testament autumn harvest festivals). For the Puritans, a Sabbath-like observance of Sunday included many of the Old Testament Sabbath strictures except one: They observed it on Sunday and conflated the Sabbath with the Lord’s Day.

The Adventists had a point: Why were Protestant Christians observing “the Sabbath” on Sunday when these Protestants did not accept the authority of the Catholic Church? And the Sunday-keeping Protestants pretty much had as their only defense one word: tradition.

Then the Adventists turned to the Catholic Church and demanded to know on what authority the Church had changed the Sabbath from Saturday to Sunday. Rather than open up to examination the charge that a “change” had been made, many Catholic apologists accepted the underlying assumption and sought to defend the Church’s authority to “change the Sabbath.”

In the day of the Lord

But when we turn from popular defenses of the Catholic faith to the sources the Church has authoritatively handed on, a blurry picture shifts into focus. The Catechism of the Catholic Church speaks at length about the relationship between the Sabbath and the Lord’s Day (CCC 2168-2195). It notes that the Sabbath is a testament to creation (quoting Exodus, not Genesis, in doing so; CCC 2169) and is “a memorial of Israel’s liberation from bondage in Egypt” (2170).

Although there is still a bit of conflation of the Sabbath with the Lord’s Day in this section of the Catechism (e.g., 2170), careful distinction is made between these two holy days. Paragraph 2175 explains that “Sunday is expressly distinguished from the Sabbath which it follows chronologically every week; for Christians [Sunday’s] ceremonial observance replaces that of the Sabbath,” and paragraph 2190 concludes that “The Sabbath, which represented the completion of the first creation, has been replaced by Sunday which recalls the new creation inaugurated by the Resurrection of Christ.”

Throughout the Old and New Testaments, there is prophetic reference to a coming “day of the Lord.” It will be a day of awe and wonder (Joel 2:31; Mal. 4:5; Acts 2:20; 2 Pet. 3:10), a day of judgment (Isa. 13:9; Jer. 46:10; 1 Cor. 5:5), a day of sacrifice (Zeph. 1:7-8). We might wonder how anyone could withstand such a momentous day as the one Scripture predicts. Without divine grace, no one could do so. Perhaps one way in which divine grace prepares us for this day is in weekly doses.

John Paul II linked the Sabbath and the Lord’s Day to eternity: “By contrast, the Sabbath’s position as the seventh day of the week suggests for the Lord’s Day a complementary symbolism, much loved by the Fathers. Sunday is not only the first day, it is also ‘the eighth day,’ set within the sevenfold succession of days in a unique and transcendent position which evokes not only the beginning of time but also its end in ‘the age to come’” (Dies Domini 26).

John Paul’s observation that the Sabbath and the Lord’s Day stand as weekly memorials to the first creation, to the new creation, and to the world to come echoes a mysterious reference to divine rest in the letter to the Hebrews: “So then, there remains a Sabbath rest for the people of God; for whoever enters God’s rest also ceases from his labors as God did from his. Let us therefore strive to enter that rest, that no one fall by the same sort of disobedience” (Heb. 4:9-11). If the sacred author was referring to a Christian observance of a weekly Sabbath, then it seems strange that he suggests a one-time entering into divine rest that could be lost permanently and definitively. This divine rest (Hebrew, shabbath, or “rest”) makes the most sense when viewed as an entrance into the eternal rest of God’s immediate presence.

Here is how Catholics should answer the Seventh-Day Adventist who challenges us to explain why the Catholic Church changed the Sabbath from Saturday to Sunday:

“The Church did not alter the day of the Sabbath. The Sabbath is the preeminent holy day of the Jewish people and remains on the seventh day, Saturday. But Christians need not observe the Sabbath. It was the capstone of the first creation. The world began anew in Christ when he rose from the dead on the first day of the week, and that is why the Church, by the authority granted to it by Christ himself, transferred the moral obligation for communal worship and rest to Sunday.”

(Image: Cross and sun, Pixabay.)