Book Review: "Of Thee I Zing"

Title: Of Thee I Zing: America's Cultural Decline from Muffin Tops to Body Shots
Author: Laura Ingraham, with Raymond Arroyo
Publisher: Threshold Editions
Page count: 308 pages
Note: Read in hardcover
Grade: D

You are Christmas shopping in midtown Manhattan when you find yourself confronted by a panhandler. You consider yourself "a caring person" but you have become burned out by all the times you have given food, coffee, and offers of job assistance to beggars on the street, only to have your hard-earned charity literally thrown back at you. This panhandler is different though. He holds up a sign explaining his plight: "I Just Need Beer Money."

Do you walk on by, muttering to yourself over the decline of society? Laugh and whip out your smartphone to immortalize him on Facebook? Head into the nearest 7-Eleven to buy him a beer? Or do you give him twenty dollars for "refreshing honesty"? If you are Talk Radio Diva Laura Ingraham, the obvious answer is to fork over $20 while complaining for personal profit about the panhandlers who were not enterprising enough to turn begging into performance art.

Of Thee I Zing: America's Cultural Decline from Muffin Tops to Body Shots, co-authored by Laura Ingraham and EWTN's Raymond Arroyo ("The World Over"), was recently featured on Arroyo's news show, during an interview conducted with Ingraham by her collaborator. I've never listened to Ingraham's radio show but I am familiar with her work. She is much admired in conservative Catholic circles as a celebrity Catholic convert and right-wing talk maven. I'm generally not interested in talk radio and have not followed right-wing talk since Rush Limbaugh's television show was canceled in the mid-1990s. Interest in American culture's decline got me to watch the interview and pick up the book.

If the book had been titled People Do the Darndest Things, it might have deserved a higher grade. Genuinely hilarious stories of overindulged children, oblivious adults, wacky celebrities, and strange cultural phenomena abound. Ingraham offers plenty of anecdotes to tickle the reader's funny bone, while giving herself a chance to vent about her favorite peeves. But for a book subtitle that promises cultural commentary, she offers no reflection at all on how things came to such a sorry pass or what can be done to turn things around—besides lecturing strangers to shut their filthy mouths around her own precious darlings and throwing a lit cigarette back into the car of a driver who tossed it to the street in her path.

Raymond Arroyo's contribution to the book is unclear. The television interview and the cover credit left me with the impression that this was a collaboration, but the book is entirely told in the first person by Ingraham. Did he provide material that Ingraham incorporated into her writing? Did he interview Ingraham and then ghostwrite the book for her? Who knows? So, I'll assign both of them the blame for not creating a narrative with a beginning, middle, and end, but a series of sketches organized into chapters and puffed into an overpriced hardcover.

If you are looking for rib-tickling observations about family life and American culture, you'll save a lot of money if you head to the local library and check out compilations of Erma Bombeck's or Andy Rooney's old columns. If you want probing commentary on the state of civilized society in the form of an etiquette treatise, try Miss Manners. The only reason I can see to spend $25 on Laura Ingraham's 300-page kvetch session is if you are a fan of her radio show. Even then, I recommend waiting until it hits the remainder tables.

(Image: Blackbird, fox, and books; Pixabay.)