Book Review: "Beyond Priests"

Title: Beyond Priests: The Future of Ministry in the Catholic Church
Author:
Paul Collins
Book Publisher:
Sheed & Ward (2025)
Review Publisher: U.S. Catholic (October 2025)

Paul Collins is an Australian journalist, historian, and former Catholic priest who, while in active ministry, was interested in the historical roots of his chosen profession. His new book Beyond Priests: The Future of Ministry in the Catholic Church outlines the challenges clergy face, arguing that some influences on the modern priesthood “are at best questionable, even unorthodox.” Ultimately, he calls for upending the Catholic priesthood.

The challenges Collins outlines include the clerical abuse crisis, the rift between Vatican II priests and their more conservative successors, declining numbers of American Catholics, and changes in how priests are expected to minister in a secular world. At the root of many of these challenges, Collins argues, is clericalism, the church’s privileging of the ordained.

The heart of this book is Collins’ history of the modern priesthood. Surprisingly, the culprits Collins names as responsible for the hierarchical model of priestly ministry are reformers like Pope Gregory VII (1073–1085), who first tried to impose celibacy on the Western clergy. Collins believes such changemakers transformed the priesthood from a synod of community overseers to clerical vassals who ruled their parishes at the pleasure of their bishops—especially the pope. In Collins’ view, nothing less than a radical uprooting of such models of clerical rule will suffice, transforming priesthood back to diakonia (“humble service”) and de-clericalizing the priestly role.

Some readers may find this manifesto a refreshing reminder that clerics were never supposed to be worldly princelings (as Pope Leo XIV affirmed shortly before he became pope). Others might prefer a less extreme call for reform. Nonetheless, Collins’ contribution is a helpful primer on what’s at stake for the priesthood in today’s church.

(Image: Blackbird, fox, and books; Pixabay.)