The Pope, the Physician, and the Pill

In my early twenties, before I became Catholic, my gynecologist prescribed the birth control pill to regulate my menstrual cycle. When I picked up the prescription, the pharmacist explained the procedure. Showing me the “dial” packaging, he said that I was to take one pill per day. The last seven days had a different colored pill. These pills were placebos, I was told. I was to take them so that I didn’t forget to take a pill each day. I’d have my “period” (which isn’t really a menstrual period since ovulation doesn’t occur) during the week I was taking the placebos.

Over the sixty years since the invention of the Pill, generations of women have been given this protocol for taking oral contraceptives. But earlier this month, the British Faculty of Sexual and Reproductive Healthcare released new guidelines that state that “there is no health benefit to the traditional seven-day break.” British and American media fingered a surprising culprit as the reason why women had for decades been put on a “sub-optimal” contraceptive protocol: the pope.

In the 1950s, when biologist Gregory Pincus was looking around for a physician to assist him in getting FDA approval for oral contraceptives, he found the perfect candidate in John Rock. An OB-GYN who had spent decades treating women for infertility, Rock was well-respected and well-connected in the medical community. And, most importantly in Pincus’s eyes, he was a Catholic. If the team could get the Church’s approval for their new wonder drug, it would go a long way toward overturning laws that outlawed birth control.

Rock was confident that he could gain the pope’s assent. Malcolm Gladwell reported in 2000 that when Rock testified before the FDA and was challenged by a fellow Catholic obstetrician over whether the Church would approve this new contraceptive, Rock replied, “Young man, don’t you sell my Church short.”

Why was John Rock so convinced his Church would meet his expectations? In an address to Italian midwives, Pius XII spoke on the issue of recourse to the natural methods of avoiding pregnancy available at the time:

Serious motives, such as those which not rarely arise from medical, eugenic, economic, and social so-called “indications,” may exempt husband and wife from the obligatory, positive debt [of the procreation of children] for a long period or even for the entire period of matrimonial life. From this it follows that the observance of the natural sterile periods [to have marital relations] may be lawful, from the moral viewpoint.

Rock’s Pill contained progestin, a form of progesterone, which is a hormone that a woman’s body produces to stop ovulation while a child is gestating in utero. He theorized that giving women doses of a hormone that their bodies already produce for the purpose of doing exactly what that hormone is supposed to do would amount to assisting the body in its natural function. And, if Pius XII had already said that sex during naturally sterile periods was acceptable, then why not sex during sterile periods maintained by a hormone the woman’s body already produced?

So, then, why did Pincus and Rock think they needed to create monthly “bleeds” that simulated natural menstruation? The recent reports focused on Rock’s desire to convince the Church that this was a “natural process” and that ensuring women still had “periods” would aid that effort.

Rock’s desire was certainly a factor, but there were other factors. When he was treating women for infertility, Rock gave his patients hormones to simulate pregnancy, his theory being that if a woman’s body experienced the symptoms of pregnancy then she could more easily become pregnant in actuality after stopping the hormone therapy. Although this worked for some of his patients, others were deeply disappointed that they weren’t really pregnant. When Rock shared this with Pincus, they decided that women needed to know on a monthly basis that they weren’t pregnant.

So although these recent critical articles have focused on Rock’s goal to win the Pope’s approval, they ignore the psychological manipulation of women at work behind the scientists’ decision to give patients on the Pill the medically unnecessary pseudo-menses.

Rock’s hopes for Church approval for the Pill were dashed in 1968 when Paul VI released Humanae Vitae. Far from supporting Rock’s theory that it could be permissible for doctors to use hormone therapies to stimulate or extend naturally sterile periods in women for contraceptive purposes, the pope maintained that such an attempt is an act that “impairs the capacity to transmit life which God the Creator, through specific laws, has built into it, frustrates his design which constitutes the norm of marriage, and contradicts the will of the author of life” (13).

Rock’s error was that he didn’t understand what the Church meant by natural. He believed that since the Pill contained a hormone already produced by a woman’s body for a specific purpose, then it was “natural”—even if it was being used for the opposite purpose.

But that’s not the Church’s understanding at all. The Church teaches that the conjugal union has a fundamental purpose, “written into the actual nature of man and of woman” (HV 12), to create new life. Any act that makes use of marital relations while suppressing its purpose “is equally repugnant to the nature of man and of woman, and is consequently in opposition to the plan of God and his holy will” (HV 13). Birth control that is “natural,” then, is not about employing naturally occurring hormones but conforming to the nature with which God endowed men and women.

Even the creators of the Pill knew that what they were doing frustrated the purpose of a woman’s reproductive system. In his history of the invention of the Pill, Jonathan Eig wrote that Pincus was well aware that “there had never been a medicine made for healthy people before—and certainly not one that would be taken every day.” It was this very tinkering with the healthy function of the female reproductive system in an effort to interrupt the natural purpose for which it was made that the Church condemned.

Rock’s faith didn’t survive his disappointment. Although he had attended daily Mass for most of his adult life, he stopped practicing his faith after the release of Humanae Vitae. And, in this, he may well have been badly served not by science but by a childhood priest who passed on to him a problematic understanding of conscience: “John, always stick to your conscience. Never let anyone else keep it for you, and I mean anyone else”—an understanding that neglects to take into account the Church’s role in informing the human conscience (CCC 1783).

The tragedy of John Rock’s life is that it appears he had good intentions. He devoted his life to medicine, to trying to overcome infertility for married couples, to educating generations of physicians who would follow him. He never saw the slippery slope beneath his feet, down which we’d descend into abortion, reproductive technologies that have stripped the beginnings of human life from both sex and marriage, and a host of other social calamities.

(Image: Stethoscope, pen, and chart; Pixabay.)