Enduring myths usually have a kernel of truth that sells the fanciful part of the story. And so it should come as no surprise that myths spring up around historical events in the Church. In the case of Fatima, there is a convergence of supernatural phenomena (the appearance of the Blessed Mother and the miracle of the sun) and a historical event that challenges ordinary human belief.
Fatima was also one of the first events of the twentieth century to draw press coverage as it unfolded. We might think that real-time press coverage would have prevented the rise of mythology, but we need only look at the 1969 moon landing to see that this need not be the case. Humans are capable of denying the truth of what occurs before their very eyes.
Let’s look at some of the myths surrounding Fatima, working from the incredible to the seemingly plausible.
MYTH ONE: Invasion of the Lucia snatchers
Some people have decided that the child seer who lived for nearly ninety years following the events at Fatima must have died young and been replaced by an impostor.
Marian T. Horvat laid out her case for an impostor having replaced Sr. Lucia dos Santos (1907-2005) at the website TraditionInAction.org. After presenting several side-by-side photos of “the two Sister Lucys” and dismissing common-sense explanations—such dental treatment, weight gain, and the ordinary rigors of aging—as superficial differences, Horvat gets to the heart of her theory: a lack of what she considers “proper behavior” for a visionary and Sr. Lucia’s acceptance of the legitimacy of Vatican II.
In her analysis of Sr. Lucia’s behavior, Horvat relies on photographs that show a Lucia as “solemn, composed, and reserved ... a person unaccustomed to being photographed, a bit awkward and uncomfortable with it.” Sr. Lucia, according to Horvat, was at this point “the person who saw our Lady and understood the gravity of the message and the role she should play in it. Her expression also fits with a person who saw hell, as she did on July 13, 1917.”
By contrast, the photos of presumed impostor supposedly show that she smiles too much, is not only no longer “timid” but at ease mingling with public figures, and lets a male friend put his arm around her. This is presented as proof that the impostor Sr. Lucia “no longer seems anxious about the future, her mission, a coming chastisement, the corruption of consecrated souls, or the many other concerns she had before. She seems optimistic and content.”
I am reminded here of a friend’s observation about the movie Into Great Silence, a documentary about Carthusian monks at the Grande Chartreuse in France. When the movie showed lingering headshots of monks who were asked to look into the camera, she noted that the younger monks were uncomfortable and fidgety, while the older monks were serene and still. Decades of religious life had transformed the older men, and they no longer displayed restlessness or discomfort with scrutiny.
The major concern for Horvat is that Sr. Lucia evidently accepted the reforms of Vatican II: she never spoke out against the council, and she even received Communion standing! Rather than demonstrating her fidelity to her vow of obedience as a consecrated religious, Horvat instead presents this as evidence that the “real” Sr. Lucia must have somehow been silenced and replaced by an impostor.
The kernel of truth around which this myth is built is that Sr. Lucia was cloistered for her entire adult life. This makes it easier to persuade oneself, if one is so inclined, that someone who retired from public life may not be the same person she was before she largely disappeared from public view.
MYTH TWO: Popes whiffed on Russian consecration
During the apparition of Our Lady of Fatima in July 1917, the Blessed Mother showed the children a vision of hell, predicted that a worse war than the one raging at the time would break out, and said, “To prevent this, I shall come to ask for the consecration of Russia to my Immaculate Heart, and [for] the Communion of Reparation on the First Saturdays. If my requests are heeded, Russia will be converted and there will be peace; if not, she will spread her errors throughout the world, causing wars and persecutions of the Church.”
Note that the request for a consecration of Russia was not yet made. Our Lady told Sister Lucia, “I shall come to ask,” which indicates her request for a consecration would be a future event.
Twelve years later, on June 13, 1929, after the Communist revolution and the establishment of the Soviet Union, our Lady returned to Sister Lucia and said, “The moment has come in which God asks the Holy Father, in union with all the bishops of the world, to make the consecration of Russia, promising to save it by this means.” (The timing of this revelation demonstrates that God did not intend the consecration of Russia to prevent the Communists from taking power.)
According to the World Apostolate of Fatima, USA (wafusa.org), subsequent popes did seek to fulfill this request. Pope Pius XII consecrated the world to the Immaculate Heart of Mary in 1942; he consecrated Russia to the Immaculate Heart in 1952. But these consecrations lacked the participation of the world’s bishops and so did not fulfill the conditions asked for by the Blessed Mother.
In its history of the events leading up to the release of the Third Secret, the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith stated that Pope John Paul II arranged in 1984 for a consecration of the world to the Blessed Mother—with special mention of “those individuals and nations which particularly need to be thus entrusted and consecrated”—in “spiritual union” with the world’s bishops “convoked” for that purpose.
Despite Sister Lucia’s acknowledgment that the 1984 consecration fulfilled Our Lady of Fatima’s request and had been accepted by God, Fatima conspiracy theorists argue that a consecration of the world, with an implied consecration of Russia, does not fulfill the request. The truth nugget that Our Lady of Fatima specified Russia, while the 1984 consecration did not, allows them to justify agitating for a specific consecration of Russia.
What these folks fail to understand is that the consecrations prior to 1984 did not fulfill the request not because Russia was not named but because the world’s bishops did not participate. In 1942, the world was at war; in 1952, a new Cold War had just begun. Both of these wars, in their own ways, hindered collegial action by the world’s bishops.
In 1984, the Cold War was ongoing, but global communications had significantly improved. A collegial consecration of the world by bishops around the world, in communion with the pope, became possible.
As for naming Russia specifically, the idea that a certain formula of prayer is absolutely necessary or God cannot accept the prayer is a form of superstition. The Catechism of the Catholic Church states:
Superstition is the deviation of religious feeling and of the practices this feeling imposes. It can even affect the worship we offer the true God, [such as] when one attributes an importance in some way magical to certain practices otherwise lawful or necessary. To attribute the efficacy of prayers or of sacramental signs to their mere external performance, apart from the interior dispositions that they demand, is to fall into superstition (CCC 2111).
MYTH THREE: There’s gotta be more to the Third Secret
At the July apparition at Fatima, Our Lady entrusted to the children a secret in three parts. The first part of the secret was the vision of hell, and the second part was the prediction of the triumph of the Immaculate Heart of Mary after the conversion of Russia. As for the third part, Sr. Lucia did not reveal that until 1944, when she was asked to write down the third part under obedience.
Sister Lucia noted on the envelope containing the third part of the secret that it “can be opened in 1960 by the Cardinal Patriarch of Lisbon or by the Bishop of Leira.” It is important to note that the instructions do not indicate merely who may open the envelope at a particular time. They note a date on which the envelope can be opened.
In essence, it is an instruction that the secret should not be read before 1960, not that it must be read in 1960—or that it had to be revealed to the public at all. In fact, in 2000 Sister Lucia told Archbishop Tarcisio Bertone that she was the one who decided on the date of 1960, based on a personal intuition.
Over the decades since the third part of the secret was given to the Vatican for safekeeping, it was rumored that popes and other members of the Church’s hierarchy had read it. As late as the 1990s, journalists attempted to cajole those with knowledge of the secret to give details. In the book-length interview Salt of the Earth, Peter Seewald tried to coax then-Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, at the time head of the CDF, into answering questions about the secret. Ratzinger refused and politely indicated that he wanted to change the subject.
Finally, in the Jubilee Year 2000, in conjunction with the beatifications of Francisco and Jacinta Marto, the two other child seers of Fatima, John Paul II authorized the release of the third part of the secret. In preparation for this event, John Paul II sent Archbishop Bertone to interview Sr. Lucia regarding the contents and interpretation of the secret.
Sr. Lucia verified the contents of the secret, but said, “I wrote down what I saw; however, it was not for me to interpret it but for the pope.” When offered an interpretation of the vision prepared by the Church, Sr. Lucia said that it corresponded to the vision she had experienced, and she believed the interpretation was accurate.
In The Message of Fatima, a document released by the CDF with the approval of John Paul II, the secret is revealed to have been a vision of a bishop dressed in white who walks through a devastated city and ultimately is cut down in a hail of bullets and arrows (see sidebar p. x). Since the attempt on his life on May 13, 1981, the anniversary of the first apparition of Our Lady of Fatima, John Paul II believed that the third secret predicted his near-fatal experience.
The CDF document affirms this interpretation, although it includes the sufferings of the other popes of the twentieth century and confirms that the historical events predicted are “in the past.” The document concludes, “Those who expected exciting apocalyptic revelations about the end of the world or the future course of history are bound to be disappointed. Fatima does not satisfy our curiosity in this way.”
Predictably, the conspiracy theorists were unsatisfied. They argued that the “bishop in white” could not be John Paul II, since he survived the assassination attempt. They also argued about the content of the secret, insisting that it could not have been fully revealed. The fact that they had no way to prove additional content existed did not deter them. They simply argued from Our Lady of Fatima’s supposed “silence” about what the vision might mean.
There is, of course, the kernel of truth that Our Lady of Fatima evidently did not fully explain the third part of the secret. Why not? We have no way of knowing. To claim that she “must” have done so, despite the fact that Sr. Lucia did not record any such explanation and that she affirmed the authenticity of the contents of the secret in 2000, is to argue for the existence of hidden knowledge that all the players have denied having. It also calumniates Sr. Lucia and all who took part in the release of a secret they were not obligated to reveal to the world to begin with.
A desire for hidden knowledge
Insistence on perpetuating myths about Fatima, despite reassurances from the Church that the events of those apparitions have been fully revealed, betrays a desire for hidden knowledge. Gnosticism, which has popped up in various forms throughout Church history, has always presented a challenge to orthodox Christian belief. The Catholic Encyclopedia defines it this way:
[Gnosticism is] the doctrine of salvation by knowledge. ... Whereas Judaism and Christianity, and almost all pagan systems, hold that the soul attains its proper end by obedience of mind and will to the Supreme Power, [in other words] by faith and works, it is markedly peculiar to gnosticism that it places the salvation of the soul merely in the possession of a quasi-intuitive knowledge of the mysteries of the universe and of magic formula[s] indicative of that knowledge.
We can see gnostic tendencies at work in the insistence that an impostor replaced the real Sr. Lucia—mainly because the real Sr. Lucia did not conform to the expectations of some adherents of Fatima, and she did not affirm them in their rejection of the Second Vatican Council.
Gnosticism is also present in the belief that the consecration of Russia was not performed because the prayer of consecration didn’t include the word Russia. This betrays reliance on a magic formula rather than on a prayer authorized by the pope and accepted as satisfactory by the surviving visionary of Fatima.
Then there is the insistence that the Third Secret was not fully revealed; that there must be “something more” out there, withheld by a nefarious Church.
Kernels of truth may sell myths, but those kernels are not of truth in its fullness. Catholics believe that God has entrusted to the Church the fullness of truth we need for our salvation and for the salvation of the world. The Church teaches that private revelations such as Fatima complement and support the fullness of the truth, which is never secret.
Throughout the ages, there have been so-called “private” revelations, some of which have been recognized by the authority of the Church. They do not belong, however, to the deposit of faith. It is not their role to improve or complete Christ’s definitive revelation, but to help live more fully by it in a certain period of history. Guided by the magisterium of the Church, the sensus fidelium knows how to discern and welcome in these revelations whatever constitutes an authentic call of Christ or his saints to the Church (CCC 67).
(Image: Child seers of Fatima, Pixabay.)