Book Review: "The Theology of The Passion of the Christ"

Title: The Theology of The Passion of the Christ
Author:
Monica Migliorino Miller 
Publisher: Alba House 
Page count: 170 pages
Note: Review published as "Passion Fruit" (This Rock, July 2005)

When an artist is faithful to his subject, his art can contain depths he never sought to incorporate. Such is the case with Mel Gibson and his 2004 film The Passion of the Christ. As screenwriter and film critic Barbara Nicolosi notes in her preface to Monica Migliorino Miller’s The Theology of The Passion of the Christ, even Gibson himself found that he had difficulty explaining to skeptical viewers the significance of certain scenes in his film. “Explaining why the image [of the ugly baby] affected us all so strongly is the job of the theologian,” Nicolosi comments.

In undertaking that job, Miller examines various theological themes of The Passion, particularly the uniquely Catholic Marian and eucharistic themes. Reading Miller’s observations on these themes will enrich future viewings of the film by those who, like Gibson, know there is rich meaning to the film’s images but have difficulty explaining exactly what they are seeing.

Gibson’s Mary, in contrast to other cinematic portrayals of the Blessed Mother, is actively involved in her Son’s Passion, to the extent that one chagrined Evangelical Protestant pastor sarcastically noted that “they should have named the film The Passion of Jesus and Mary” Such a thought obviously horrified him, but a Catholic would nod in agreement and find the suggestion apt. As the prophet Simeon predicted (Luke 2:34–35), Mary suffered alongside her Son, a detail finally fully captured on film by Gibson and noted by Miller. Among the powerful scenes used to show Mary’s suffering are her presence at Christ’s scourging, her retrieval of his eucharistic blood spilled by the scourging, her accompaniment with him on the via dolorosa in counterpoint to Satan, and her active participation at the foot of the cross that culminates in her pleading with her Son to allow her to die with him.

Miller, originally mildly critical of the violence in The Passion (see “Flaw of Blood,” This Rock, May-June 2004), has since pondered the film’s bloodiness more deeply and drawn out more completely its theological significance. She cites a reviewer of the film who noted, ” The Passion isn’t just a gruesome movie but a ritual that exalts the blood of Jesus because the release of this blood released humanity from sin.” Skeptical critics of the movie saw the blood as just so much blood. But the faithful recognize that the precious blood of Christ is salvific and eucharistic. Glorying in that blood is the opposite of the “sadomasochism” the film’s critics allege; it reflects instead a deeply Christian joy in the source of human salvation.

Miller explains well, in opposition to the claims of critics, that the movie is biblically based, but she also draws upon the visions of Christian mystics, especially the recently beatified Anne Catherine Emmerich, as recorded in her book The Dolorous [i.e., Sorrowful] Passion of Our Lord Jesus Christ. Although many critics dismissed the movie because of its dependence for artistic detail on the writings attributed to Emmerich, Miller explains that interpretations of the Gospels are common to other Jesus movies and plays, such as The Last Temptation of Christ and Jesus Christ Superstar. What should matter is not that the Gospels are interpreted but whether they are interpreted in a manner faithful to orthodox Christian tradition.

Although Miller is evenhanded in her treatment of the controversial issues surrounding Emmerich—including that Emmerich’s writings were to some extent influenced by the antisemitism of her time and culture—it would have been helpful from an apologetics perspective to explain the role of private revelation in the Catholic faith. It is also important to understand that the writings attributed to Emmerich are believed to have been highly embellished, perhaps even falsified, by Emmerich’s secretary M. Clemens Brentano to such an extent that Emmerich’s cause for sainthood was delayed for nearly a century and progressed only when the Church excluded the writings attributed to her from consideration of her life. Thus, though it is unobjectionable for Gibson to have drawn neutral material from the writings to flesh out his adaptation of the Gospel accounts of the Passion, the writings themselves cannot be considered authoritative.

Unlike many movies produced today, Mel Gibson’s The Passion seems destined to become a movie classic that each new generation will experience as a cinematic rite of passage. In contrast to such secular predecessors as The Wizard of Oz and Gone with the Wind, The Passion may be the first religious movie to attain such a distinction. And when new viewers approach The Passion of the Christ, they will find The Theology of The Passion of the Christ to be a handy guide to the theological meaning of the images they experience in the movie.

(Image: Blackbird, fox, and books; Pixabay.)