The young preacher stepped up to the pulpit to continue his series of lectures for the catechumens preparing for baptism. His topic was the liturgy, and the preacher wanted to make certain the catechumens were prepared to receive the Eucharist in a reverent and worthy manner.
“In approaching [for Communion] therefore, come not with your wrists extended, or your fingers spread; but make your left hand a throne for the right, as for that which is to receive a King. And having hollowed your palm, receive the body of Christ, saying over it, ‘Amen.’ So then, after having carefully hallowed your eyes by the touch of the holy body, partake of it; giving heed lest you lose any portion thereof; for whatever you lose is evidently a loss to you as it were from one of your own members.”
The time was not the 1980’s, the place was not a suburban American parish, and the preacher was no Father Feelgood. The year was mid fourth century, the place was Jerusalem, and the preacher was St. Cyril—possibly a priest at the time, he would become Bishop of Jerusalem and a Doctor of the Church—and the words were his Catechetical Lecture 23.
A little history
St. Cyril took for granted that Communion would be distributed in the hand. Not only that, he took for granted that Communion in the hand can be done in a reverent fashion. Note his instruction about a communicant blessing his eyes by touching the consecrated host to them before consuming the host. This is not an option the Church allows for today—communicants must immediately consume the host after receiving it in the hand—but it is an indication that the consecrated host not only is not profaned by being touched by the communicant but that the Eucharist makes holy that which it touches.
A couple of centuries after St. Cyril’s time, the Church in the West reached the conclusion that Communion on the tongue should be adopted as the normative means for the faithful to receive the host. Pope St. Gregory the Great (590-604) worked to standardize the custom of offering Communion on the tongue by disciplining priests who continued to adhere to the older practice. By the seventh century A.D., the Church in the West judged Communion on the tongue necessary to instill in the faithful a better understanding of and devotion to the Real Presence of Christ.
Communion in the hand was revived in the Latin Church as part of the liturgical reforms of the mid twentieth century, in an effort at ressourcement, or a return to the earlier sources of the Church before the Council of Trent. Where aggiornamento was a modernization of the Church, ressourcement was the principle that modernization should be under-girded by a return to original sources of Church teaching. One of the leading voices for ressourcement at Vatican II was the young priest-theologian Joseph Ratzinger, who became Pope Benedict XVI.
Current Church discipline
These days, the practice of Communion in the hand is controversial among orthodox Catholics. The current universal discipline of the Latin Church is that Communion is offered to the faithful on the tongue. Some countries have received a dispensation by the Holy See from this universal discipline, allowing the faithful to choose to receive Communion in the hand (unless the host has been dipped in the precious blood by the minister of Communion, in which case it must be received on the tongue).
The U.S. Church has the dispensation allowing for Communion in the hand. The U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops gives this instruction for reception of Communion by the faithful in Norms for the Distribution and Reception of Holy Communion Under Both Kinds:
Holy Communion under the form of bread is offered to the communicant with the words “The body of Christ.” The communicant may choose whether to receive the body of Christ in the hand or on the tongue. When receiving in the hand, the communicant should be guided by the words of St. Cyril of Jerusalem (41).
The current practice for reception of Communion by the laity in the United States allows for the laity to receive Communion in the hand. It is not required; it is a permission granted under appropriate circumstances (cf. Redemptionis Sacramentum). In fact, the Church acknowledges that there can be circumstances under which a priest might choose to restrict distribution of Communion to placing it on a communicant’s tongue. For example:
Special care should be taken to ensure that the host is consumed by the communicant in the presence of the minister [of Communion], so that no one goes away carrying the eucharistic species in his hand. If there is a risk of profanation, then Holy Communion should not be given in the hand to the faithful (RS 92).
There are cases in which the Eucharist has been subjected to profanation because congregants did not consume Communion in the presence of the minister. Over the years I have been an apologist for Catholic Answers, I have heard many horror stories of hosts found in pews, on the floors of churches, stuck between pages of hymnals, even found embedded in wads of discarded chewing gum. If possible, the abuses of the Eucharist can become even graver when Communion is taken to the homebound.
Catholics are rightly appalled when they hear of profanation of our Lord’s body and blood, sacramentally present under the appearances of the consecrated bread and wine. In recent years, such cases have led a number of priests and laypeople to ask whether permission for Communion in the hand ought to be revoked. Certainly a case can be made for revoking the permission for Communion in the hand. Profanation of the Blessed Sacrament is a grave evil, and the Church needs to address it.
But a case can also be made that there is no need to discard an ancient custom of the Latin Church because the consecrated host has sometimes been abused. To argue that Communion in the hand must be abandoned because some laypeople do not receive it in their hands in worthy fashion is akin to arguing that priestly celibacy must be abandoned because some priests do not keep their vow to celibate chastity.
Suggestions for receiving Communion
How should we respond when we are concerned about the practice of Communion in the hand? Here are some suggestions.
Do not overreact. If Communion in the hand is an issue that bothers you, it is fine to make your opinion known and to argue for a return to Communion on the tongue. But if your purpose is to change hearts and minds, it is self-defeating to make outrageous claims—for example, that Communion in the hand is more offensive to our Lord than the murder of children in the womb. (This is example is not an exaggeration. I have heard Catholics make this claim.) Keep your claims modest and within your ability to substantiate with direct quotes from the documents of the Church.
Make an informed, but not rigid, decision. When I was being catechized in preparation for baptism, my RCIA class was taught both methods of receiving Communion. At the time, I chose to receive in the hand. A few years later, I transitioned to receiving Communion on the tongue because, in my personal opinion, I thought it to be more reverent. To this day, I generally receive Communion on the tongue. Occasionally though, when I have cold sores on or near my mouth, I receive Communion in the hand. There may be cases in which it could seem appropriate to make an exception to a general rule for how you receive Communion. If so, do not scruple over making those exceptions.
Avoid rash judgment. Many Catholics in the U.S. choose to receive Communion in the hand. For some, it may be how they were taught to receive Communion; for others, they may simply prefer to receive the host in their hands because the Church allows them to do so. It is uncharitable to assume that these Catholics receive Communion in the hand out of bad faith, or that they are offending God by their choice. The Catechism of the Catholic Church says:
Respect for the reputation of persons forbids every attitude and word likely to cause them unjust injury. He becomes guilty ... of rash judgment who, even tacitly, assumes as true, without sufficient foundation, the moral fault of a neighbor (CCC 2477).
Regarding rash judgment, the Catechism goes on to note:
Every good Christian ought to be more ready to give a favorable interpretation to another’s statement than to condemn it. But if he cannot do so, let him ask how the other understands it. And if the latter understands it badly, let the former correct him with love. If that does not suffice, let the Christian try all suitable ways to bring the other to a correct interpretation so that he may be saved (CCC 2478).
Focus on the Lord. For the most part, how individuals receive Communion at Mass is not the concern of their fellow members of the congregation. It is the primary responsibility of the ordinary and extraordinary ministers of Communion, not of individuals in the pew.
Certainly, if a Catholic happens to see a host drop to the floor—or, God forbid, notices someone abscond with a host—he has the right and obligation to inform either a minister of Communion of an immediate problem (e.g., a dropped host) or his pastor of a grave problem (e.g., theft of the Blessed Sacrament). Such circumstances, though, likely will be rare incidents for most people.
For most Catholics, most of the time, there is little need to pay attention to how anyone else receives Communion. Rather, if all of us resolve to mindfully focus on how we personally receive our Lord in Communion, and then offer our gratitude for that gift in interior prayer, we will not be scandalized by how others receive. In so doing, we may even be able to offer reparation for any profanation that does occur.
I ask everyone, especially ordained ministers and those who, after adequate preparation and in cases of genuine need, are authorized to exercise the ministry of distributing the Eucharist, to make every effort to ensure that this simple act preserves its importance as a personal encounter with the Lord Jesus in the sacrament. ... All Christian communities are to observe the current norms faithfully, seeing in them an expression of the faith and love with which we all must regard this sublime sacrament (Benedict XVI, Sacramentum Caritatis).
(Image: Christ the King, Pixabay.)