Title: Why the Jews Rejected Jesus: The Turning Point in Western History
Author: David Klinghoffer
Publisher: Doubleday
Page count: 247 pages
Note: Review published as "Jews and Christians" (This Rock, September 2005)
Why the Jews Rejected Jesus: The Turning Point in Western History by David Klinghoffer provides for Christians a historical overview of the Jewish rejection of Jesus of Nazareth as the Messiah. He argues that the Jews rejected Jesus because they believed that to accept him would necessitate jettisoning the Sinai covenant between God and the Jewish nation. Christians, Klinghoffer suggests, should be grateful for this rejection of Jesus, because without it Christianity would have remained a Jewish sect rather than becoming the mother of Western civilization.
Klinghoffer, an Orthodox Jew, offers a powerful argument that, if evangelical progress is to be made, Christians and Jews first must begin to take each other seriously. But in offering Jewish responses to Christian evangelism, Klinghoffer unwittingly demonstrates the great failure of both Christians and Jews to give each other due credit as educated believers in sophisticated religious traditions. Klinghoffer gives an image of this dynamic with his metaphor of the “alternative realities” he asserts that Christians and Jews inhabit:
In one reality, the truth of Jesus’ messiahship is obvious to anyone who takes an honest look at the biblical sources. In the other reality, Jesus as Messiah is a proposition that would be hard to take seriously were there not so many intelligent and earnest Christians who stake their lives on it.
On the Christian side, this is expressed in the Christian fondness for documenting the fulfilled Old Testament prophecies. The eager Christian missionary too often assumes that all he must do is line up the Old Testament prophecies with the evangelists’ New Testament documentation of their fulfillment and any “honest” Jew will be compelled in conscience to be baptized or prove himself “hardhearted.” As Klinghoffer demonstrates, this approach fails to appreciate that a biblically literate Jew may read those Old Testament passages from a vastly different perspective that finds little support for the idea that Jesus is the Messiah.
On the other side, Klinghoffer’s analysis of the New Testament underestimates Christianity. As one example, Klinghoffer offers “proofs” for his skepticism of Paul’s Jewishness. One “proof” is his assertion that Paul identified himself with the Gentiles: “Once, in composing his letter to the community at Galatia, the apostle made an intriguing slip in his choice of pronouns, writing as if he himself were a non-Jew: ‘that in Christ the blessing of Abraham might come upon the Gentiles, that we might receive the promise of the Spirit through faith’ [Gal. 3:14].”
When read in context, this text affirms Paul’s Jewishness. Moreover, it makes sense that Paul, who by the time of this letter had been apostle to the Gentiles for years, would readily identify himself with those to whom he was specially called to evangelize. Klinghoffer should have expected this Christian rejoinder and dealt with it.
Why the Jews Rejected Jesus has considerable weaknesses, but to the extent that it leads Christians to a better understanding of and respect for post-Christian Judaism, it will make them better evangelists for Christ.
(Image: Blackbird, fox, and books; Pixabay.)