Title: Christianity's American Fate: How Religion Became More Conservative and Society More Secular
Author: David A. Hollinger
Book Publisher: Princeton University Press (2022)
Review Publisher: U.S. Catholic (March 2023)
Raised in the Anabaptist tradition, retired Berkeley historian David A. Hollinger is an atheist descended from a long line of ministers. After a career spent exploring the intersections of American religiosity and secularization, Hollinger pulls together several strands of thought from previous books into a fresh analysis of the growing divide between American evangelicalism and secularism.
“When non-Christians learn of disputes between different groups of Christians,” Hollinger writes, “they may remark, ‘I don’t have a dog in that fight.’ ” Hollinger believes they do, considering the influence evangelicals wield in politics and culture. American Catholics “have a dog in this fight,” too. The church in the United States has seen an influx of converts from evangelical traditions who are attracted by the very religious authority their forebears once rejected. Initially fleeing mainline Protestant churches that were softening their stances on sexual morality and opening pathways to women in ministry, these converts influence the growing conservatism of American Catholic clergy.
The crux of the problem for Hollinger is that the United States has become “an increasingly secular society ... saddled with an increasingly religious politics.” Nearly a third of Americans no longer identify as religious but live and work within a society in which conservative evangelicals and their Catholic allies have an outsized influence on American politics. For Christians, Hollinger argues, the problem is the tension between the apostle Paul and philosopher Immanuel Kant. Do they choose the smaller, doctrinally pure Pauline tradition or Kant’s vision of “universal moral and epistemic solidarity”?
Americans are at a crossroads right now. Time will tell which path will be taken. Hollinger’s book is a helpful map showing how we reached this point in the journey.
(Image: Blackbird, fox, and books; Pixabay.)