Book Review: "Sweet Valley Confidential"

Title: Sweet Valley Confidential: Ten Years Later
Author: Francine Pascal
Publisher: St. Martin's Press
Page count: 304 pages
Note: Read in Nook format
Grade: C-minus

The mid-1980s. Tween sensations and fraternal twins, Mary-Kate and Ashley Olsen, had barely emerged from their mother's womb when their older sisters, not yet an identifiable marketing demographic, were following the adventures of Elizabeth and Jessica Wakefield. The 16-year-old identical twins, California blondes with perfect size-six figures, developed a devoted fan following among the junior-high set who had just outgrown their Barbie dolls. Like the rest of my peers, I eagerly trailed after The Wakefield Twins, competing with classmates to borrow the latest releases in the popular series from the school library. Copies were so coveted that the library kept them behind the checkout desk.

I remembered those days recently when I heard that series creator Francine Pascal, who wrote the plot outlines for the books that were then given to ghostwriters to produce, had written an adult novel about the lives of The Wakefield Twins ten years after high school. I was immediately dubious. Could someone who had not written a Sweet Valley book "cover to cover" do justice to these characters, even if she had conceived the series and developed the plots of the installments for ghostwriters? Or would she be another George Lucas, having no idea of the limits of her strengths and ruining a beloved franchise?

Elizabeth Wakefield has moved to New York, having quickly pulled up stakes in Sweet Valley when she discovered that her twin and her longtime Ken-doll (um, I mean boyfriend) Todd Wilkins have been carrying on a long-term affair behind her back. Sensible, serious Liz, the friend magnet who can't help but attract people wherever she goes, is Friendless in New York, eking out a miserable existence writing theater reviews for a start-up publication.

Well, Elizabeth isn't entirely friendless. She has her best friend, Bruce Patman, whose transformation from alpha wolf to beta pup came after the deaths of his parents in a car accident years ago, helped through by dependable Liz. He has nurtured an unrequited crush on the oblivious Elizabeth ever since. Meanwhile Elizabeth, who has never before been known to indulge in vengeance against her twin despite all of Jessica's past betrayals, is determined now to avenge herself on Jessica and Todd.

There are enough twists and turns in the continuing drama of the citizens of Sweet Valley to satisfy any soap opera fan. Shocking Revelations abound—someone's exited the closet, it's not Bruce Patman as I originally feared, but someone nearly as implausible—but do little to prop up a tell/don't show writing style. All's well that ends well, as with every good soap, with one major couple literally walking off into the sunset. If you were hoping for an adult novel, and classify that as something more gripping and gritty than the Wakefield matriarch dropping an F-bomb in public, this isn't it. And if you outgrew Sweet Valley long ago and aren't a soap fan, there's not much more on the menu here.

There are nice moments. I liked the Big Scene between Elizabeth and Bruce, even if it was dropped from the sky by smiling Fates. The concept for the book might have worked if Pascal had once more turned over this book-length plot treatment to an experienced ghostwriter, preferably one who had worked on one of the original series. Out of sentiment from a one-time Sweet Valley fan who still has a few of my favorite SVH books on my shelves, my grade is a C-minus. Someone not feeling as kindly as I toward the franchise likely would be less generous.

(Image: Blackbird, fox, and books; Pixabay.)