Title: And the Rest Is History: The Famous (and Infamous) First Meetings of the World's Most Passionate Couples
Author: Marlene Wagman-Geller
Publisher: Perigee
Page count: 241 pages
Note: Read in hardcover
Grade: C
Had Ralph Waldo Emerson given serious thought and more than a passing glance to strangers exchanging smoldering looks, perhaps he would not have been so quick to declare that "All mankind love a lover." Indeed, had the American Transcendentalist read through some of the tales of lust run amok in Marlene Wagman-Geller's And the Rest Is History, the experience might have led him to conclude that not every coupling into which human beings manage to hook themselves deserves so lofty a label as "love."
A mere sampling of the stomach-churning tales masquerading under love's ennobling robes include Jean-Paul Sartre and Simone de Beauvoir, who treated the date of a pact to remain "committed emotionally" while carnally promiscuous as a "wedding anniversary"; Prince Charles and Mrs. Andrew Parker Bowles, who competed with each other in classless proposals (Charles indisputably "won" with his desire to be reincarnated as Camilla's tampon); and Abelard and Heloise, the archetypal medieval precursor to the Church's many sexual abuse crises down the centuries. Some of the stories are saved from complete debasement by surprising poignancy. Two examples would be Alice B. Toklas's deathbed conversion to Catholicism, completed by her plaintive question to her priest whether her conversion meant that she could look forward to eternal reunion with her lover, Gertrude Stein; and Joe DiMaggio's long held torch for Marilyn Monroe (who would likely have ended life better had she been capable of remaining Mrs. Jim Dougherty).
One major problem with And the Rest Is History is Ms. Wagman-Geller's consistent myopia both in her choices of subjects and in her nearsighted focus on their presumed "love" with scant perspective or context. Just looking at the British royal couples she chose to include, I found myself wondering why the macabre Queen Victoria and Prince Albert, the hedonistic King Edward VIII and Wallis Simpson, and the tasteless Prince Charles and his married woman made the cut, while excluded from the pantheon of Most Passionate Couples were the devoted Queen Elizabeth II and Prince Philip, the steadfast and dutiful Prince Albert and Lady Elizabeth Bowes-Lyon (Queen Elizabeth's parents), and the classy Prince William of Wales and Catherine Middleton (engaged months before this book's publication date).
It can't go unmentioned that this book is also marred by a lack of competent proofreading, which might have saved the author the embarrassment of such howlers as Napoleon Bonaparte crowned in 1884 (p. 27); Clark Gable and Carole Lombard married in 1931 "during a few days' break [from filming] on Gone with the Wind" (p. 122); and a famously disputed spelling of the name of the King of Rock and Roll, who was dubbed at birth Elvis Aron Presley, not "Aaron" (p. 175). To be fair, the last example is the subject of controversy, but in quasi-biographical literature of this kind the controversy should either have been noted or avoided (by leaving out unnecessary mention of Presley's middle name). In any case, catching as many errors as this in a book of under 250 pages can leave the reader pondering the author's credibility as a historian.
So, with all these problems, why give the book a C grade? The book is genuinely entertaining and engrossing, and I finished it in one sitting. A few of the stories were charming enough that I'd be interested in learning more about the lives and love shared by Leonard Woolf and Virginia Stephen (Woolf), George Burns and Gracie Allen, Desi Arnaz and Lucille Ball, and Patrick Swayze and Lisa Niemi. The stories of these couples cheered me immensely, left me a tad less cynical about the possibilities of romantic love, and washed away a bit of the sour taste left by the sordid yarns that posed as love alongside these examples of the real thing.
(Image: Blackbird, fox, and books; Pixabay.)