Michelle Arnold

Michelle Arnold

What Suffering Saints Can Teach Us

The other day I came across this arresting headline on Aleteia.org: “Meet a ‘Cinderella saint,’ a powerful intercessor for abused children.”

The article was about St. Germaine Cousin, a sixteenth-century French peasant girl who died young after a life of suffering from disabilities and malnutrition, abuse from her stepmother, and neglect by her father. Unlike the cinder girl who was swept away from a life of drudgery by her Prince Charming, Germaine’s hardship remained to the very end:

One morning in the early summer of 1601, her father finding that she had not risen at the usual hour went to call her; he found her dead on her pallet of vine-twigs. She was then twenty-two years of age.

Many Catholics are uncomfortable with stories like Germaine’s, in which a saint suffers horrific abuse without complaint but responds with what seems to be superhuman piety. For example, one winter when Germaine’s stepmother accused the child of stealing scraps of food that Germaine was taking to the poor, and those scraps were miraculously transformed into summer flowers, Germaine offered the flowers to her stepmother “as a sign of [God’s] forgiveness.”

Who does that? How can we possibly imitate such virtue? And is this how victims of abuse are supposed to act?

As I’ve written before, imitation of the saints doesn’t necessarily mean that we must copy their specific actions. As the Catechism notes, the Church offers us “the example of [the saints’] lives, the transmission of their writings, and their prayer today” (2683).

In mathematics, an example is a sample problem that a teacher uses to demonstrate how to solve other math problems. Students aren’t being asked to solve the sample problem, but to use the sample problem as a template for solving their own problems. Analogously, we learn from the saints’ lives how to apply the mandates of the gospel of Christ to our lives.

In a story like that of Germaine Cousin’s, the takeaway lesson is not necessarily that we should give flowers to our abusers rather than seeking relief and justice; rather, we see a radical response to Christ’s mandate to answer evil with love (Rom. 12:17–21) and can use that response as inspiration for figuring out ways in our own lives to respond with love when faced with evil.

Okay, some might say, but what about the specific example? Why would the Church elevate Germaine Cousin to the altars and give a spotlight to her response to abuse? No one denies that a child who lived such a hard life and acted with such Christian charity in response to her afflictions must now be in heaven, but the Church canonizes saints precisely to hold up their lives as models of heroic virtue. Why not spotlight a saintly person who courageously confronted her abuser and found safety in this life?

A first thing to note is that the Church does give us examples from other saints who had various forms of abuse in their backgrounds. Servant of God Dorothy Day lived with a man who treated her derisively for her interest in Catholicism and her desire to baptize their daughter. They fought often, and finally Day refused to continue living with him. Shortly afterward, she and her daughter were received into the Church. (But that wasn’t the end of the story. Day remained lifelong friends with her daughter’s father, and he joined their daughter at Day’s funeral, including the memorial Mass, after she died in 1980.)

The Church doesn’t offer us just one pattern of sanctity, or only one example from which to draw inspiration—but many. If we have trouble relating to one saint’s way of holiness, we can always draw close to another.

As the Aleteia article pointed out, though, another reason the Church offers us saints like Germaine Cousin is to provide intercessors for those who personally identify with her life story. The tragic reality is that there are many children who live with abuse similar to what Germaine endured. By officially recognizing Germaine’s sanctity, the Church offers victims of abuse a patron in heaven who understands precisely what they are going through and can intercede in a special way for them with God. Scripture assures us that we can have hope for ourselves because we know that those in heaven have endured to the end and triumphed, beginning with Christ himself:

Since then we have a great high priest who has passed through the heavens, Jesus, the Son of God, let us hold fast our confession. For we have not a high priest who is unable to sympathize with our weaknesses, but one who in every respect has been tempted as we are, yet without sin. Let us then with confidence draw near to the throne of grace, that we may receive mercy and find grace to help in time of need (Heb. 4:14–16).

Finally, although Germaine Cousin’s life doesn’t really bear comparison to fairy tales beyond her evil stepmother, there is something to be said for the nature of fairy tales and what they can tell us about our hope for conquering evil.

In his essay On Fairy Stories, Catholic writer J.R.R. Tolkien coined the term eucatastrophe, the “sudden joyous ‘turn’” that offers grace and hope where none could be expected:

This joy, which is one of the things which fairy-stories can produce supremely well, is not essentially “escapist,” nor “fugitive.” It does not deny the existence of dyscatastrophe, of sorrow and failure: the possibility of these is necessary to the joy of deliverance; it denies (in the face of much evidence, if you will) universal final defeat ... giving a fleeting glimpse of joy, joy beyond the walls of the world.

This young girl lived a life of horrific suffering, for which there can be no rationalization or excuse. And, yet, she managed within her short, pain-filled life to love God to a heroic degree, fulfilling her ordinary duties as a shepherdess for her family’s flock while sacrificing what little she had to give to the poor. When her family finally offered her a place in their home, she chose to remain where she was because she preferred it, making her own choice to stay for love for God. Her holy death soon afterward was the eucatastrophe, the sudden turn from a bitter existence to eternal beatitude. Germaine wasn’t “rescued” in this life to a better life on earth, as was Cinderella; she was rewarded with seeing God face to face.

Tolkien quoted Thomas the Rhymer, a medieval Scottish poet, who suggested that it is precisely the trials we suffer in this life that create the narrow way to heaven (Matt. 7:13–14). Fighting our way through those sufferings, as did St. Germaine Cousin, ultimately brings us closer to God.

O see ye not yon narrow road
So thick beset wi’ thorns and briers?
That is the path of righteousness,
Though after it but few inquires.

(Image: Statue of thinking man, Pixabay.)