By Joy Bergmann
Reckless drivers in New York City are receiving far fewer moving violation summonses from NYPD officers than they did in 2019, prior to the pandemic and George Floyd protests, according to NYPD’s July 2023 traffic data.
Comparing year-to-date July 2019 stats to July 2023, officers citywide have issued 32% fewer total tickets to drivers.
NYPD 2023 moving violations year-to-date for offenses that strike fear in the hearts of pedestrians like red light running, distracting cell phone use, failing to yield to pedestrians, and speeding are markedly down compared to the same period in 2019:
NYPD did not provide an explanation when asked why ticketing remains far below 2019 rates. An NYPD spokesperson did supply this response via email:
“While it is true that throughout the city there has been a decrease in moving violation enforcement when comparing 2023 to 2019, it should be noted that enforcement has risen each year since 2020 and continues to rise in 2023. Enforcement is trending in a positive direction.”
Some cops say they are more reluctant to make traffic stops since the NYPD began requiring collection of demographic information [race, gender, age] about stopped drivers in 2022.
“You’d have to be crazy to do a traffic stop now,” said a veteran officer on condition of anonymity, calling the requirements another “attack” by groups “driven to prove bias” in policing. “It breaks my heart that people make it impossible to do the job.”
Others object to such objections.
“Police officers fill out paperwork all the time. If you don’t want to be accountable, if you don’t want to do the job, then do something else,” said Christopher Dunn, Legal Director of the New York Civil Liberties Union, in a February 2022 interview.
While NYC is missing out on the revenue and scofflaw deterrence provided by vigorous police enforcement, the city is seeing fewer fatalities, according to NYPD.
“In 2023, overall traffic deaths have decreased vs. 2022 and vs. 2021 year to date in NYC,” wrote the NYPD spokesperson. “New York City, and New York State as a whole, have lowered pedestrian traffic deaths, as many states in the nation have actually seen a tragic increase in pedestrian traffic deaths.”
The NYC Department of Transportation (DOT) recently noted that, “the first half of 2023 has thus far been the safest ever year for pedestrians on record,” excluding 2020 as an anomalous year when many people were in lockdown. Pedestrian fatalities are down by nearly 20 percent through the first seven months of 2023, with 61 pedestrian deaths in 2022, versus 49 during the same 2023 period, according to a DOT spokesperson.
DOT credits the now 24/7 operation of 2,000 speed cameras in NYC with improving traffic safety. “One year ago we launched 24/7 speed camera enforcement, and the results are in: the program has reduced speeding, decreased the number of injuries, and made our streets safer,” said NYC DOT Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez.
However, NYPD-issued speeding tickets are arguably more painful to drivers.
Speed cameras issue $50 fines to the registered owners of vehicles caught exceeding the city’s default 25 mph speed limit. According to a DOT report, this is far less than the cost of a summons issued by a police officer for speeding in a school speed zone (where many of the speed cameras were placed). Such NYPD tickets could run $90-$600, depending on the motorist’s speed and prior record, plus an $88 State surcharge. Drivers would also face points on their individual license with ramifications for insurance rates.
Due to current New York State law, only 150 red light cameras can operate at any given time at NYC’s approximately 13,200 signaled intersections. Red light camera violations are also $50 fines issued to the vehicle’s registered owner. A pending bill in Albany would increase the available red light cameras in NYC to 1325.