GPs should take on long-term ADHD management, landmark review recommends

anilakkus via Getty Images

GPs should take on long-term management of ADHD under nationally-mandated shared care arrangements, the landmark Government review into ADHD and autism has recommended.

Independent government advisors also called for a ‘clinically-led review’ of ADHD and autism assessment waiting lists to prioritise those with the most urgent need.

At the top of the list for rapid assessment should be those with severe functional impairment, self-harm, safeguarding concerns, imminent school exclusion or at risk of unemployment, the expert panel chaired by Professor Peter Fonagy concluded.

A detailed review commissioned by former health secretary Wes Streeting also called for stricter oversight and regulation of all providers of autism and ADHD assessments and a ban on direct-to-consumer advertising of services offered by NHS-funded private providers.

In addition, the NHS should also move from ‘episodic specialist care’ for ADHD to long-term management by GPs backed by a consistent national standard for shared care agreements ‘so people are not left stranded between services or reliant on private prescriptions once diagnosed’.

Those with mild to moderate need who do not need urgent assessment should get more support while waiting, the 500-page report concluded.

But no one should be removed from a pathway without assessment, communication and discussion with each person receiving a response ‘proportionate to their needs’, the report authors added.

It forms part of the ‘radical reform’ needed in the support for people with autism, ADHD and common mental health disorders, the review found, with a move away from a ‘diagnosis-dependent’ system to one that is ‘needs-led plus diagnosis’.

Early intervention from multidisciplinary teams based in neighbourhood hubs should be available without the need for a formal label, the report authors recommended.

In response, the Government pledged that children, young people and adults experiencing mental distress will ‘receive broader support and advice at the earliest opportunity, without having to wait for a clinical diagnosis’.

And it agreed to strengthen regulation around ADHD and autism assessments, and review advertising practices.

An interim report had already found that sharply rising diagnoses and referrals for ADHD and autism do not appear to be explained by changes in population prevalence.

It reported that services are under ‘significant and sustained pressure’, and that the status quo is ‘unlikely to be sustainable or fair’.

The final report concluded that a lack of data and research meant it was difficult to state whether overdiagnosis was happening ‘at scale’ but the risk will become more likely if present trends continue.

It does not mean people’s distress or difficulties are not real, the report stressed. ‘The problem is a system that leans too heavily on diagnosis as a route to help and cannot keep pace’, it added.

Extreme pressures on the system, brief assessments and single-condition pathways, all increase the risks of misdiagnosis and over-medicalisation that can cause harm, the report found.

The review also found that the prevalence of common mental health disorders, such as depression and anxiety in young people had increased by 50% since the early 1990s, with four million children and young people – one in five – in serious distress.

And co-occurrence of common mental health disorder with ADHD and autism traits is high, the data shows.

Drivers for mental health issues include increased uncertainty, financial pressures, insecure work, unaffordable housing, and ‘a lack of hope amongst young people that their lives will be better than their parents’, said Professor Fogerty.

Social media impact on sleep, a decreased sense of community belonging, and reduced access to youth services, are all also likely to contribute.

Digital and AI tools should be used for sign-posting and triage with ‘clear routes to immediate human escalation’, the report said.

‘The current system is failing patients, professionals and the public, said vice-chair Professor Simon Wessely.

He said the fault was one of systems not individuals trying to get help, and that included the ‘ad-hoc’ way in which private providers were being used by the NHS to tackle demand.

‘We and many others, including most GPs now, have concerns about the quality of the assessments being performed by some providers and the incentives behind this.’

The review found that spending on independent-sector ADHD provision has risen by around 252% in three years, ‘yet this large and fast-growing use of public money’ is happening ‘without consistent oversight, transparency or quality assurance’.

Vice-chair Professor Gillian Baird added: ‘One of the most important recommendations is that instead of a diagnosis-dependent system, where you don’t get anything unless you’ve got a particular label, we now move to a needs-led system plus diagnosis, in which intervention is early, the moment people perceive that they’ve got a problem.’

Assessment and services need to be available locally in neighbourhoods, she said, adding that ‘we are also proposing that there should be integration of neurodevelopmental and mental health services’.

Health secretary Yvette Cooper said: ‘It is clear that mental health services need to change to focus more on the early support young people need to stay in education or work or keep their lives on track.

‘We will set out our response in a new Mental Health Strategy in the coming months, building on the new mental health services we are already providing in schools and in the community.’

She added the Government would also ‘take action to strengthen the oversight of mental health and neurodevelopmental services, and make all diagnostic assessments for ADHD and autism CQC-regulated, so people can be confident that assessments are high quality and that the NHS is not being overcharged by independent or private providers’.

Professor Miranda Wolpert, director of mental health at Wellcome, said the review was an important contribution to understanding how to better respond to the growing burden of mental ill health.

‘Real progress will come from scaling evidence-based approaches for those who need it most. This will mean people receive help earlier and reduce long-term impacts on their education, employment and health.’

Thea Stein, chief executive of the Nuffield Trust, said: ‘With compassion and rigour, this report brings much-needed focus to the growing levels of distress we see across the population, particularly among young people.

‘It makes a powerful case that we have asked too much of diagnosis and simultaneously done too little to provide the practical support needed by people experiencing distress.’

The system it suggests is sensible but will only work if ‘support is actually there’, she added.

‘The knotty question for policymakers is how we decide who needs clinical care and diagnosis and who can be better helped through support in work, school and wider society.’

A recent Pulse survey of over 800 GPs found that seven in 10 believe ADHD is overdiagnosed.