An Australian Border Force officer who believed she had been in a “loving relationship” with a colleague for almost two years is suing her former lover for defamation after discovering he had secretly accused her of being a sexual predator, a Queensland court has heard.
Brisbane-based ABF officer Erin Weatherall has told the Queensland District Court her lover first levelled the allegation against her in July 2017.
In a statement of claim filed in the court by Ms Weatherall, she said she was so blindsided by the “devastating” complaint she told investigators at the time: “That’s ridiculous. I’ve never blackmailed anyone for sex.
“The only male officer that I’ve had sex with is Tony Kelly.”
The 36-year-old claimed Mr Kelly had vehemently denied it was him and she had continued their relationship for another 15 months, unaware the man she “loved and trusted” was her accuser.
She said the relationship had started in January 2017 after he told her he was separated from his wife, who had “mental health issues”.
But she alleged that unbeknown to her at the time, ABF internal investigators had confronted Mr Kelly six months later, wanting to know whether he was in an extra-marital affair with her.
Ms Weatherall said instead of telling the truth, Mr Kelly told investigators: “(Ms Weatherall) has been trying to blackmail me, threatening to call my wife and tell her about our affair and the pregnancy. She’s blackmailing me so that she can have sex with me.”
In an interim judgment in December, judge Ray Rinaudo said Mr Kelly had repeatedly assured Ms Weatherall it wasn’t him, even after the ABF allegedly removed her from active duty in August 2017.
He had also acted as Ms Kelly’s “support person”, attending work meetings with Ms Weatherall and her superiors after she had been suspended from duties.
On one occasion, Mr Kelly allegedly told her regional commander, in front of Ms Weatherall: “I don’t know where the blackmail claims have stemmed from, it must be jealous co-workers.”
Judge Rinaudo said Mr Kelly had also called on his own father, Wayne Kelly, the then principal legal adviser for the Queensland Racing and Integrity Commission, to represent Ms Weatherall.
He said Mr Kelly had later refused to represent her, citing a “conflict of interest, although he did not disclose what the conflict was’.
“Why the respondent made the allegations against (Ms Weatherall) is not known, particularly in the circumstances where having made the allegation, he continued a relationship with (Ms Weatherall) for a considerable period of time during which he allegedly continued to deny that he had made the statements,” Judge Rinaudo observed.
He said Ms Weatherall’s health quickly deteriorated, forcing her to be admitted to hospital in December 2017 for a perforated kidney, collapsed lung and pneumonia.
“The applicant states that she lost 13kg between August and December 2017 due to being unable to eat because of stress and anxiety about being investigated for an accusation she considered to amount to her being a sexual predator,” Judge Rinaudo said.
He said that by January 2018, Ms Weatherall had been diagnosed with depression and anxiety, then in June 2018 Mr Kelly allegedly asked her whether she wanted to have a baby with him.
“On 14 August, 2018, the applicant told (Mr Kelly) she was thinking about killing herself because she couldn’t cope with the false allegations against her,” the judge said. A month later, she ended the relationship, but it wasn’t until October 2018 that (she) finally discovered it had been Mr Kelly who had accused her of blackmail.
“Clearly, it would have been devastating for her to find out some 15 months after allegations were made against her that the person with whom she was in a loving relationship had been the perpetrator of the allegations in the first place,” the judge said.
“I accept that she would have been humiliated in the workplace and even more so once it became apparent who the alleged perpetrator of the allegations was.”
A Department of Home Affairs spokesman said the Australian Border Force “take the safety, physical and mental wellbeing of its employees very seriously and has a range of support and review mechanisms that staff can, and do, access when required”.
“We respect the privacy of employees, and their families, and cannot comment on individual cases or personal circumstances,” he said.
Mr Kelly’s legal team has yet to file a defence.