Artist and the artless: stepdaughter exploited dying mum for $2.2m

Artist John Olsen's stepdaughter, Karen Mentink, leaving Moss Vale court. Picture: Adam Yip
Artist John Olsen's stepdaughter, Karen Mentink, leaving Moss Vale court. Picture: Adam Yip

It was the ugliest of family brawls: Australia’s most treasured living artist, John Olsen, pitted against the fury of his grasping, unemployed stepdaughter, Karen Mentink.

At the heart of the dispute was a secret $2.2m “gift” Mentink claims her mother gave her, “out of the blue”, just weeks before she died in December 2016.

The huge windfall, Mentink insisted, had also been a deathbed revenge by her mother — Katharine Olsen — who had become convinced her 91-year-old artist husband had found himself a new girlfriend.

But a scathing judgment by NSW Supreme Court judge John Sackar on Friday seems to have left little room for doubt that it was Mentink who had taken advantage of her mother, well aware her terminal brain cancer had dramatically changed her mother’s personality and left her confused, fragile and entirely dependent on her daughter.

Justice Sackar said the 58-year-old Mentink had been so obsessed with getting what she believed was her fair share of her mother’s estate that she had taken her mother to the local bank branch in October 2016 — two months before her death — where her mother transferred the $2.2m directly into her daughter’s account.

Mentink, the judge said, had been worried about whether she might have to pay tax for the “gift”, but at no point did she suggest her mother should get legal advice. It was a callous act of “selfishness and utter self-indulgence”, he said.

“The defendant (Mentink) denied any suggestion that she had influenced her mother into giving her the $2.2m or, in fact, influenced her change of mind. However, I reject her denials.

“She was, in my view, plainly ignoring her mother’s vulnerability and instead was focused on her own material gain.”

Justice Sackar has yet to determine whether the $2.2m can be returned to Katharine Olsen’s estate. But his condemnation of Mentink’s treatment of her mother has come as a huge relief to Olsen family members, who remain traumatised that Mentink was ever able to worm her way into such a trusted position.

Insiders say Katharine Olsen had been a “striking, tall woman” with a “feisty personality” who had often argued with her daughter over money.

The artist’s fourth wife, she had been running a bed-and-breakfast in Wentworth Falls in the NSW Blue Mountains when she first met Olsen, who was 61 and fresh out of his third marriage. But, say insiders, she had quickly refashioned herself into “the manor born”.

By the time Katharine Olsen fell ill the couple had been married for 27 years and were happily settled at their Hidden Lake homestead in the NSW southern highlands. Observers say the couple lived on opposite sides of the homestead — Olsen bunkered in his studio while Katharine ran a large stable and dabbled in local property investments. But they always came together for “a nice dinner”.

“At one point Katharine had 47 horses,” a family insider tells The Weekend Australian. “All her grand lady fantasies, all her whims, were indulged. John’s motto has always been ‘a happy wife means a happy life’. He was like the golden goose, keeping the whole thing afloat.”

Mentink was 28 when Olsen came into her mother’s life. Despite claims in court about how close she was to her stepfather, the artist’s staff gave evidence they had rarely seen Mentink at Hidden Lake before she moved in to take care of her mother in her final months.

Giving evidence at the trial, Olsen said his wife had tried to warn him just before her death: “Karen is after money and the properties.”

Olsen said he’d ignored it at the time, largely because Mentink had long been in the habit of asking the couple for money, including a new kitchen for her home and school fees for her children.

After his wife died his relationship with Mentink changed, he told the court. She would allegedly turn up at the house unannounced and take items — ceramic pots, an autumn-coloured raincoat, a valuable English teapot and tiny paintings by Sally Aurisch.

“There was constant pilfering,” Olsen told the court.

Peter Farley, the gardener at Hidden Lake, gave evidence that within months of Katharine Olsen’s death valuable paintings “seemed to disappear” from the couple’s barn. “There were a lot of prints and a couple of Brett Whiteley paintings and a Ben Quilty painting stored up in the barn and some of those seemed to disappear,” he told the court.

Farley said in his affidavit he had seen Mentink carting items out of the main house after her mother’s death. “One day I was talking to John in the kitchen and I saw Karen walking in front of the house holding a painting.

“John said, ‘Oh my word, look at this. That painting is worth a lot of money. How much does this woman want?’ ”

But it was Mentink’s eulogy at her mother’s private funeral, when she referred to Olsen as “the bank”, that “really shocked” the artist, Farley told The Weekend Australian. “She started talking about all the great trips overseas she’d had with her mother and thanking John for giving her and her mum a life “up at the pointy end of the plane”, Farley recalled.

“I felt so sad for John to have to hear that kind of thing at his age. He was so generous and kind, and she just abused it.”