Border Force lover ‘threatened to drive car off cliff and kill them both’

Erin Weatherall allegedly warned Tony Kelly: ‘If you ever leave me, I am going to f. k you over’. Source: Supplied
Erin Weatherall allegedly warned Tony Kelly: ‘If you ever leave me, I am going to f. k you over’. Source: Supplied

A married Australian Border Force officer who allegedly told his bosses he was being “blackmailed” into continuing an affair with a female colleague claims his former lover threatened to drive both of them over a cliff if he dumped her, according to court documents.

Tony Kelly, a former Queensland policeman, is being sued for defamation by 36-year-old Erin Weatherall over allegations he made false and “malicious” complaints to the ABF, casting her as a “sexual predator”.

In documents before the Queensland District Court, Ms Weatherall said the ABF had first confronted her with the allegation in August 2017 but refused to tell her who had made the “devastating” complaint.

She told the court as a result she had continued her relationship with Mr Kelly for another 15 months, unaware the man she had “loved and trusted” was her accuser, and still living with his wife.

Border Force officer Tony Kelly. Picture: Supplied
Border Force officer Tony Kelly. Picture: Supplied

In a notice of intention to defend the defamation action, filed in court on Friday, Mr Kelly has denied defaming Ms Weatherall, insisting he had been duty-bound to inform his ABF bosses about the strain the extramarital relationship was causing him and explain his deteriorating work performance.

Mr Kelly, 38, rejected Ms Weatherall’s allegations he told her he had been separated from his wife because of her mental health issues, insisting she knew he was married and had “remained in a sexual relationship with his wife” throughout their affair.

In his defence document, Mr Kelly alleges when he first tried to end the affair in May 2017, Ms Weatherall allegedly warned him: “If you ever leave me, I am going to f. k you over.”

He alleged Ms Weatherall had also threatened to tell his wife she had terminated a pregnancy to him.

He also revealed two of his supervising officers had known about his affair with Ms Weatherall well before a formal complaint was made, but he said when they asked him how he was coping on July 17, 2017, he had lied to them, claiming he was heading to Cairns for a fishing trip with his brother when in fact he was joining Ms Weatherall for a holiday.

He says when one of his bosses rang him three days later to tell him he knew he was with Ms Weatherall in Cairns, he told his supervisor he had felt pressured into the holiday as “it was part of the deal I had with Erin to help her to get over the abortion”.

Mr Kelly said his boss had then ordered him to return to work in Brisbane immediately, but Ms Weatherall had allegedly threatened him: “If you go back to Brisbane, I am going to drive this car off this cliff and kill us both.” Mr Kelly said he had to take an $8000 pay cut in a new role as an investigator because of the relationship.

Ms Weatherall has been on leave without pay since January 2018 after her health deteriorated and she became suicidal.