A year in, Trump’s re-election campaign evokes déjà vu

For how unprecedented Donald Trump’s third bid for the presidency has been — and that may be understating it — some experts report a sense of familiarity. From the way he speaks to the way he acts, Trump is running a lot of the same plays that got him into office in 2016 and nearly repeated the trick in 2020.

Of course, the elephants in the room are his four ongoing criminal cases. They are the most clear differences in his 2024 campaign, but in true Trump fashion, he has weaponized the 91 felony charges against him to galvanize his supporter base. According to Emerson College Polling, it is working: as of September 2023, he holds a eye-popping 47% lead over the next challenger.

“He has, every time he has been indicted, gone up in the polls among Republican voters,” said Linda Schacht, a former White House and congressional communication staffer. “He has pulled away from his closest competitor, [Florida Governor] Ron DeSantis, steadily, ever since the indictments have begun.”

According to Schacht, this is just the newest page in the Trump playbook. She cited his expertise in running campaigns that are “based on grievance” and called his newest campaign just another application of that expertise.

It is clear that even though his political career has gone deep into uncharted territory, he is applying his strengths. In fact, outside of having to deal with the impact of his criminal charges on his campaign, everything else he is doing is remarkably similar to the tactics he is best known for: working the media and playing the victim.

“He loves to play the victim. He did it a lot in 2016, he did it a lot in 2020, and now he’s doing it in probably the most amplified fashion I’ve ever seen,” said Dr. Tammy Vigil, an associate professor at Boston University specializing in political campaigns.

However, not everybody is as glowing in their assessment of how Trump is being affected by and dealing with his ongoing litigation. Matt Taglia, senior director at Emerson College Polling, cited the sheer drain that fighting 91 felony counts is.

“Having to show up to court, having to dedicate mental resources, physical resources, financial resources, that’s time, effort and money,” Taglia said. “That takes away from his campaign, plainly.”

That being said, the only major consideration for Trump this time around is his unique position as both a former incumbent as well as a challenger. As such, a decision that, on its face, seems foolish — not participating in the debates leading up to the Republican primary — is actually fairly logical.

“He has nothing to gain by being part of the debate[s], and that’s true of most incumbents,” said Vigil. “It means he actually gets to control the conversation a whole lot more, and he draws attention away from the debates.”

At the end of the day, Trump’s greatest asset is that, for all his messaging about being an outsider and challenging the system, he has become an establishment figure in terms of being thoroughly backed by the Republican party. They want to win as much as he does, and the voter base that he brings with him is enough to overlook all the negativity he also carries.

“He certainly has become not just a leader of the party. He is a party, for a lot of people. They are more committed to him as a person than they are to any political party,” Schacht said. “As long as he can command that attention and command that devotion… he’s going to sail to the nomination.”

Now, the question becomes this: what’s next? A year out from the general election, all signs indicate that America will be getting a second round of Trump versus current President Joe Biden, and Vigil did not mince words in her projection of how that will play out.

“I think we have the possibility of having one of the ugliest campaigns that has ever happened in the United States, and we’ve had some ugly ones,” Vigil said. “It’s fascinating in the same way that watching a train wreck is fascinating.”