Boston leaders promote fare elimination program

Sen. Ed Markey, Rep. Ayanna Pressley, and Boston Mayor Michelle Wu rallied support for a transformational bill seeking to address the social, racial, and economic inequities stemming from the condition of Boston’s public transit in a press conference held yesterday.

Standing at an open-air podium by Ruggles station and Northeastern’s Centennial Common, the trio was joined by members of the community ranging from everyday transit riders to nonprofit leaders to city councilors. They came together to support a common cause: fare-free public transit, courtesy of the Freedom to Move Act.

The bill, which proposes subsidizing state-level transit systems’ fares and infrastructural improvements with federal grants, hit a wall after Markey initially introduced it in April 2021.

However, the Democrat seemed more enthused about its chances during this reintroduction, and so did the crowd of roughly 50 students and members of the media.

“We should see this moment as an opportunity to rebuild, reimagine, and reinvigorate our public transit systems, to fix the historic injustices that are built into the physical and operational structures of public transportation in America,” Markey said, “[and] to deliver truly accessible, affordable and safe public transportation for everyone.”

Every speaker invited to the podium mentioned those historic injustices, but none more so than Pressley, who cut to the core of the issue when talking about the gaps in quality of life between Boston neighborhoods.

“Maybe you're tired of hearing the statistics, but people are more tired of living them,” she said. “In a three-mile radius from Cambridge to Roxbury, life expectancy drops by 30 years and median household income by $50,000. Transportation has everything to do with those inequities.”

“In particular, for Black Boston bus riders, riding, waiting, [and] transferring [takes] an additional 64 hours a year. That's an additional 64 hours to get to your place of work, to get to school, to get to a health care appointment, to get to child care,” she continued.

Pressley emphasized the outsized financial burden placed on commuters of color, who use public transit more than white Bostonians. She cited a statistic claiming the average commuter spends 16 percent of their annual budget on transit, with that number rising to 30 percent for what she called “low-wage workers.” All in all, she claimed that eliminating fares and incentivizing public transit could save households over $10,000 each year.

These inequities were exacerbated by the COVID-19 pandemic, according to Markey.

“At the height of the COVID-19 crisis, ridership plummeted by over 80 percent,” he said. “Today, ridership is still down 30% across our nation. At the same time, transit agencies are struggling to recruit workers and restore services. The people of Boston know that better than anyone, and low income, Black, brown, and immigrant Bostonians know it the best.”

However, an enduring criticism of the Massachusetts Bay Transportation Authority is reliability and safety, especially in recent years. In response, Wu called out this supposed zero-sum game where reliability comes at the cost of affordability and vice-versa.

“Financial accessibility has to go hand in hand with reliability. There's no other way. And so sometimes people will say, ‘Well, why would you prioritize fare-free transit at a time when you need every single penny going to mak[ing] the system more reliable and mak[ing] those fixes?’ No one up here is saying that we have the luxury to delay fixing the system,” she said.

“In fact, we are putting forward the data and evidence that making the system more accessible to all actually improves its performance and reliability.”

To that point, she cited the three bus lines — the 23, 28, and 29 — that are halfway through their two-year planned fare-free period. Those lost fares were reimbursed by money allocated to Boston in the American Rescue Plan Act and led to a host of benefits, most notably a return to near-pre-pandemic levels of ridership, according to the Boston Globe.

“This is a moment where everyone has to rethink how we fund public transportation,” she continued. “We cannot put it on the backs of our essential workers and families who are already riding transit.”

Fare collection is a surprisingly inefficient revenue stream. According to the Globe, the MBTA only collected 24 cents per dollar in 2021 after factoring in the cost of collecting fares. Add in the cost of updating the collection system, and that number plunges to 8 cents.

“We're not talking about needing to change the direction that the sun is going or totally upend the entire system. We're talking about making the small changes to empower people who already want to be living their lives in a different way,” the mayor added. “This is critical to making sure that our entire system is one that is a vehicle, a platform, to connect people to their dreams, as opposed to a barrier.”

At-large Boston City Councilor Ruthzee Louijeune phrased this sentiment neatly by summing up the responsibility and duty of those in public office.

“The role of policy on a macro level is about looking at that which is burdening the most vulnerable,” she said. “For me, the role as a new policymaker in the city of Boston [is] all about looking at what is regressive and doing what we can to make lives easier for folks who have a hard time in our city.”