After yet another mass shooting, the same old response

There are just under two months left in 2023, and this country has already seen 35 mass shootings. With each, especially after last month’s tragedy in Lewiston, Maine, mainstream discourse on the cause of the epidemic honed in on a familiar tune: placing blame squarely on mental illness.

There is no questioning that Robert Card, the Army reservist who killed 18 people in Lewiston, was undeniably mentally ill. That being said, mental health experts pointed out one fact again and again: if he didn’t have a sniper rifle and .308 caliber bullets, that number would not have been 18, no matter how mentally ill he was.

“The most severely incapacitated mentally ill person, who has delusions from here to eternity, cannot hurt anyone unless he or she has a weapon,” said Dr. Donna Sabella, an associate professor in the University of Massachusetts Amherst’s College of Nursing.

Of course, guns are not the only weapons readily available in America. That being said, Sabella made the distinction between someone taking a knife and stabbing one or two people and someone using a high-powered rifle to shoot a dozen. Both scenarios are grim, but one more so than the other.

Sabella also raised the point that the messaging pinning such tragedies on mental health is coming from people who may not be qualified to speak on the subject.

“I don’t know any politicians who are experts in mental health,” she said. “[We’ve] got people who are saying it’s mental health who aren’t mental health professionals or experts.”

Dr. Alex McCourt of the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health agreed, noting that blaming mental illness is more of a reflex than an actual appraisal of the facts.

“People with mental health conditions are far more likely to be victims of gun violence than they are to actually perpetrate gun violence,” he said. “There’s some stigma associated with this constant jump to, ‘Oh, we need to do something around mental illness or mental health.’”

That being said, Sabella acknowledged that there is a lot of work to do in improving the infrastructure around the medical treatment of mental illness in America.

“We need more providers, we need psychiatrists, we need nurse practitioners,” she said. “We need more mental health [support].”

When asked about what the more pressing issue is, Sabella and McCourt called for laws restricting access to firearms both generally and in terms of their caliber and capacity.

“The best thing, in my mind, to do, would be to pass legislation that limits the type of arms that people can have,” Sabella said. “We don’t need these high-powered weapons.”

McCourt added that the current norm of each state implementing their own levels of restriction as opposed to the federal government setting national standards is a “patchwork approach” with “a lot of complications.”

Neither, however, were particularly optimistic about the future of gun ownership in America, with McCourt calling a universally agreed upon solution “next to impossible to find.”

“I don’t think we’re going to change [politicians], and history proves that people come in [to office] who already have a certain mindset,” Sabella said. “I don’t think anyone’s going to convince the NRA.”

At the end of the day, McCourt pointed to the simple fact that there is a vast gap between what voters want and what politicians pursue. It is an issue that extends far past gun control, but certainly one that colors it deeply.

“We've done a lot of polling research asking people what they think of these laws and people like them. They're generally supported by people across political beliefs, across gun ownership,” he said. “There is a lot of public support for a lot of these policies, but that public support isn't translating into policy action.”

“That disconnect is really important to overcome.”