January 31, 2023

Article at Al Kingsley

View original

ChatGPT use in education, for and against.

image credit Search Engine Journal
Click here to view Al Kingsley’s profile

What risk do tools like ChatGPT pose for the current education system ? An argument for and against.

Argument for:

  1. Increased access to information: Tools like ChatGPT make it easier for students to access information and learn, as they can quickly and easily ask questions and receive answers. This can potentially improve education outcomes, especially for students who may struggle with traditional learning methods.
  2. Time and cost savings: The use of AI-powered tools like ChatGPT can save time and resources for teachers, as they can automate repetitive tasks such as answering frequently asked questions. This allows teachers to focus on more important aspects of education, such as developing engaging lesson plans and providing personalized feedback to students.
  3. Personalized learning: AI-powered tools like ChatGPT can offer personalized learning experiences, tailored to the needs and learning styles of individual students. This can help students to better understand and retain information, and can also provide a more engaging learning experience.
  4. 24/7 availability: Unlike human teachers, AI-powered tools like ChatGPT can be available 24/7, providing students with access to information and support at any time. This can be especially beneficial for students who have busy schedules or who live in remote areas.

Argument against:

  1. Job loss: The widespread use of AI-powered tools like ChatGPT in education could lead to job loss for teachers and educators, as many tasks previously performed by humans may become automated. This could have negative impacts on the economy, as well as on the quality of education, as human teachers bring unique skills and perspectives to the classroom.
  2. Bias and accuracy concerns: AI-powered tools like ChatGPT are only as good as the data they are trained on, and if the data is biased, the AI models will be too. This could lead to incorrect information being taught to students, or to students receiving biased responses to their questions. Additionally, AI-powered tools may not always be able to accurately interpret the nuances and complexities of certain questions, leading to incorrect or incomplete answers.
  3. Dependence on technology: Students who become overly reliant on AI-powered tools like ChatGPT may struggle to think creatively and critically without the assistance of technology. This could lead to a decrease in critical thinking skills and problem-solving abilities, which are essential for success in many fields.
  4. Lack of human interaction: The use of AI-powered tools like ChatGPT in education can lead to a lack of human interaction, as students may interact more with technology than with their teachers and peers. This can lead to a decline in social skills and emotional intelligence, which are also important for success in many areas of life.

Overall, the impact of AI-powered tools like ChatGPT on the education system is complex and nuanced, and it will likely depend on how the tools are used and the motivations behind their deployment. While there are potential benefits to using these tools, it is important to carefully consider the risks and to ensure that they are used in ways that promote, rather than detract from, the quality of education.

So before you raise a response to the above comments, I should share that I didn't write any of this, this was the full response from ChatGPT when posed the original question " What risk do tools like ChatGPT pose for the current education system ? Write a detailed argument for and against." Not sure I agree with the impact on teaching jobs, we need the human factor more than ever, but it's interesting to see how it responds to questions about its own impact.